professor ganson wrote:MX7 wrote:Xiu Xiu - Everything.
Finally got to see them live on Sunday. An absolutely awesome experience. Everything was so different to the albums, and so well taylored to a live setting, from the throbbing death-bass to the clanging of scrap metal. Even the calmer songs seemed to have been fed through a meat grinder. It made me realise how much I fucking hate going to gigs where they just play the album back to you. Case in point: Radiohead. I used to adore that band, until I saw the limp excuse for their live show back in 2003. I might have well have listened to their singles very loud while surrounded by middle class white twats. Rarrr rarrr rarrr.
lol on the Radiohead comment. So is xiu xiu British? Because if they're American, like I thought, that's quite a tour for an indie band.
Nah, they're American! Yeah, they did quite an extensive European tour this time. I always appreciate it when smaller bands do such tours.
Sorry if I offended anyone about the Radiohead comment. I just have very strong views on what it means to perform live, I guess. A lot of people I know hold the opposite viewpoint, that a band playing very similarly to what they've recorded on the album is preferable. I can see the rationale behind this, that it can evidence exemplary musicianship by correctly emulating what could be considered to be the definitive rendition of the performance. Personally, I hold improvisation and self reinvention to be much more desirable facets. This is basically why I stopped listening to 'safe' bands like Tool and Radiohead, and moved on to more interesting bands like Lightning Bolt and Deerhoof who often perform remarkably different versions of their songs live.
I also think it derives from my dislike of big gigs in cavernous halls with perfect sound. I've seen Deerhoof twice now, once in a sailing club bar and once in a small pub/social club, both times playing on battered (borrowed?) equipment and sounding completely different both times. Now that's what makes an exciting gig
