CMoon wrote:Anyway BM, the issue really is there: Everytime Garegga is mentioned you have to tell us what is broken about it. Why? This is the gazillionth thread now where you explained to us that Garegga is broken.
That's really not quite true...at the beginning of this thread I pretty much stuck to the topic at hand (and IIRC I said more about Souky than I did about Garegga); the thing that set me off was the ridiculous "invisi-bullets are okay because they're more realistic" comment. Garegga in itself isn't what gets me going on this sort of topic (as I've said myriads of times now, in spite of its flaws I like the game a lot): rather, it's the way that arguments which would be laughed off as ridiculous and fanboyish if applied to any other game are seemingly viewed as perfectly sensible and acceptable when given in Garegga's favor. When you ask below "what's your point?" THAT is my point.
Its also the gazillionth thread where people complained because you told us that garegga is broken. You speak like your on the defense, but has it occurred to you that it's the other way around?
I guess I could see how I might be seen as being on an "offensive" of sorts...as I said, however, I'm not even "against" the game itself, just the puzzling and uneven attitude some have towards it. If people, even if they disagreed with me, offered up more sensible arguments on the subject rather than the paper-thin wackiness (usually with a generous helping of indignance on the side) I see accepted with open arms so often, I'd have no reason to ever bring this sort of thing up.
Like I said in my first post, I just don't like feeling like I'm retarded for enjoying the game.
I have NEVER so much as insinuated anything like that (one more time:
I like the game!)...again, it baffles me how people seem to automatically take my comments to their illogical extreme whenever it's on a topic like this one...
If we all agreed with you, gave you a big prize, maybe even pretended we hadn't noticed the inviso-bullets and rank ourselves, could we promise to bring up this topic only once a year?
I'm not demanding that everyone agree with everything I say, I'm just hoping that whenever the next batch of brazenly kooky justifications for shortcomings in ANY game (not just Garegga, though I tend to see it most often in connection with it) comes up, someone (hopefully not just me) will be able to offer up a proverbial "wtf?!" without being labeled as some sort of hopping-mad extremist.