Whew, a good old fashioned SNES vs. Genesis debate. This brings back memories.
Hmm, I'm almost of the exact opposite opinion. Love the Genesis 'wacky bass' sound. Anyways, here's a list of the titles for it I find to be worth playing:
Alien Soldier (here's an example of teh good graphicz00rz, btw)
Contra Hard Corps
Devil Crash
Elemental Master
Eliminate Down
Fire Shark
Ghouls n Ghosts
Gunstar Heroes
Kunio-kun Soccer
Mega Turrican
Outrun
Raiden Trad (better than the SNES version)
Road Rash 3
Rockman Megaworld
Sensible Soccer
Twin Hawk
Thunderforce 4 (See, Genesis can have good music. See Daser stage)
Wardner
Now here's the list of SNES games I'd find worth playing:
Megaman X (soon it'll be on PS2)
Super Mario Kart
Umihara Kawase (sequels on PSX are better)
Maybe a bunch of RPG's if you're into that crap.
And yeah, that's about it.
Only four good games for the SNES. Yeah...anyway, you list Contra Hard Corps for Genesis as a good game, then you don't list Contra 3 for SNES as a good game. Contra Hard Corps is a weak, watered down Contra game that exists for the sole reason that the Genesis could not handle Contra 3.
Here's just a small sample of the list of SNES games I consider to be quality titles:
Super Mario World(The first one only)
Contra 3
Donkey Kong Country(the first one only)
Castlevania 4
Darius Twin
Super Nova
Gradius 3
Star Fox
Mega Man 7
Mega Man X
Street Fighter 2, Turbo, Super, etc.
Mortal Kombat 1-3
Super Double Dragon
Killer Instinct
Art of Fighting
TMNT Tournament Fighters
Robocop vs. Terminator
Final Fight 1-3
Raiden Trad(Haven't played the Genesis version)
X-Men Mutant Apocalypse
Jurassic Park 1-2
Here's what's good for Genesis
Sonic 1
Sonic 2
Sonic 3...
Sonic&Knuckles......
Sonic Spinball............
X-Men(!)
X-Men 2
Can't think of anything else. Sagaia is OKAY but somewhat weak compared to the two SNES Darius games. I'm not a huge RPG person, I prefer games with more solid action and gameplay than games with story and characters and all that.
-SNES fans seem to have a thing for supperior Graphics and sound, not really caring if gameplay is identical, or inferior.
Why is it that almost every game that was ported to both systems was inferior in all 3 categories(graphics, sound, and gameplay) on the Genesis.
Don't try to say that a console trounced another in Every single way, because that's simply NEVER true (unless Atari Hardware is in question).
The Genesis had a faster CPU speed than the SNES. Does that make anybody happy to hear me say that? What matters most at the end of the day is the number of quality titles for each system, and I think the SNES squashed the Genesis in that category.
I find a lot more of my fave games on the Genesis rather than on the NES and SNES.
The Genesis having more good games than the NES and SNES put together...man I've heard some great ones in my day, but that one just about takes the cake.
Man, decide. Either the Snes blows out the Genesis because of its superior hardware OR specifications don't mean anything. If you want my advice, I would go with the latter.
You really can't box up my opinion into either category. I said that the SNES blew Genesis out of the water because of the number of quality titles, and have said little or nothing about graphics or specifications carrying alot of weight. Genesis had virtually all the same top developers making games on their system(Konami, Capcom, etc.) yet why is it that it seemed like every time the Genesis 'version' was a weak, crappy, watered down game in comparison to the excellent SNES version. Maybe companies like Konami are just guilty of platform favoritism, always going the extra mile to make sure the SNES version was top notch and always falling short a mile in making the Genesis version as good or better. I'll try out those games you mention but I'm not going to change my mind just like that.