heisenbergman wrote:If Prisoners and The Prestige can't "save" Jackman, then nothing can.
Prisoners?
I watched it on the plane, it's complete drivel. I was talking about an actual film role.
And even though he's the best thing in it, even the Prestige is vastly overrated.
CMoon wrote:
The PG-13 did hurt it, even though the book managed fairly well. Some things can be discrete in writing, but effectively unfilmable without hitting the more adult ratings. Obviously as an adaptation of a teen novel, R isn't an option, but neither is shaking the camera so much that you can't tell what is going on. My real beef with the film though (and honestly, it is pretty good for what it is), is how we still end up with a bunch of pretty hollywood characters instead of impoverished people fighting for survival. This is a true miss with the main characters--for example where Peeta purposely ruining a loaf of bread so he can give it to Katniss is a life or death matter--while in the film the scene feels almost trivial. One doesn't need a rated R to convey this sense of intensity and desperation, and I think the film did miss an opportunity here.
I haven't seen the new film yet, but will get around to it sometime soon.
Well it has no sense of consistency. Like you said, they're meant to be impoverished to the point of starvation, but they all look perfectly healthy - fit, even. The districts were implemented like an afterthought, so you never really get a sense of class struggle or fascism, and the TV show is handled so much like an actual TV show that it seems to be delivering it to us, the audience, with a kind of entertainment factor.
The director doesn't allow the dread to linger or settle in, and the antics in the forest are pathetic. She's the main character and she's constantly getting passes on everything, including doing any killing. She shoots one guy in a knee jerk reaction after he throws a spear into a little kid, and that's the only direct kill she has in the entire movie. Even the bad guy at the end gets fed to the dogs, and then she performs a
mercy killing.
I don't want to see a mercy killing. This is a fight for life, not a tween romance. All the "we're changing the rules","Ok we're not now!" was really ham-fisted, too.
And yeah, the shaky camera was absurd from the first sixty seconds on. Someone should sell these Hollywood types a tripod or something.