BIL wrote:Casino Royale (2006) is my favourite Bond film hands-down, the sickly dialogue between Bond and Vesper in the latter third aside, and I'd have preferred more of its brutal ilk. Mads Mikkelsen is a better antagonist than Bardem upon repeat viewing of both films, far more believably evil. But I do appreciate what they did with Skyfall. It's a throwback to the more fantastical Bond films that still maintains a more than sensible distance from the inanity of Moonraker and Die Another Day. A compromise for sure, but not the worst one.
Sounds like we're on the same page.
No Bond movie has ever been a strict adaptation of Fleming's character, but some have been closer than others. From Russia With Love and Casino Royale particularly: two movies which you also found entertaining, most probably for the same reasons. Entertaining doesn't need to mean unrealistic, underwritten, flawed.Good old Skykid, being offensive again, probably without realizing it. Look we may not agree on the merits of these films, but to imply that my opinion was swayed by flash instead substance is just to insult my intelligence. You've made quite clear that you only care about a Bond that is a strict adaptation of Flemming's Bond. I do not. I care about entertaining, well made films and I think I've done well enough to justify my opinion on Skyfall. You don't have to agree, but don't need to be insulting either.
What's amazing about Skyfall is it's thin on the most integral Bond ingredients, albeit while managing to tell an engaging story.
Breaking it down:
Bond Villain: approx 10 mins of screen time
Bond Girl: approx 5 mins of screen time
Espionage: 3/10
Intrigue: 4/10
One liners: 4/10
Theme music: 2/10
Raw Grit: 4/10
It's perfectly entertaining in a kind of TV Drama matinee way, and the relationship with Q was the film's best theme and M probably the best new character. It's a much better 'film' than most of Moore's carry-on, Brosnan's superman and Dalton's feeble stand-in, and for that reason it's in the upper end of the spectrum - but in terms of a Bond film, I just can't believe the hype.