Who cares what the AFI says?CMoon wrote:RE: JawsIt's really hard to say. Look, there's no question in my mind that Jaws is a 10/10 film, but when you start saying best 10 American films, or best 10 Hollywood films, it does become very subjective. I mean, every film on that list (and a much longer one) are going to be 10/10 films, so from there it is your call. Certainly if the AFI said Jaws was top 10, I couldn't really argue with them.Skykid wrote:I think you're probably right if you categorise the top 10 'American' films, but what if you categorise the top 10 Hollywood films (as in, films in the same commercial vein.) Then it would be in the top 10 right?CMoon wrote:I don't think it's in the top 10 american films, but definitely the top 50.
It's what you think that counts. Film Institutes and judging bodies don't know jack shit about jack shit. Look at the Oscars, it's a joke.