Recommended Anime/Manga?

A place where you can chat about anything that isn't to do with games!
User avatar
Skykid
Posts: 17655
Joined: Sun Nov 18, 2007 2:16 pm
Location: Planet Dust Asia

Re: Recommended Anime/Manga?

Post by Skykid »

drauch wrote:^Gunbuster is amazing! The ending is a real treat for my sci-fi-fandom.
Guys, thanks for this recommendation!

DL'd this today based on your comments, it's something I'd always meant to watch. Just done the first 2 episodes and it's already awesome. Funny how the themes are almost completely concurrent with many of today's anime, yet somehow it's done 1000 times better, lol.

Will probably comment in the other anime thread once I've finished them all. :wink:
Always outnumbered, never outgunned - No zuo no die

User avatar
Siren2011
Banned User
Posts: 793
Joined: Sat Feb 12, 2011 6:51 pm
Location: The sky on my television set.

Re: Recommended Anime/Manga?

Post by Siren2011 »

I'm so glad you're watching and enjoying it, Skykid! :D If you're impressed so far, then you will shit bricks during episode 4.
It's sequel OVA (which I recommend you torrent immediately after finishing this one), features different characters/buster machines and similar scenarios. Hidaeki Anno only supervised on the project (Kazuya Tsurumaki of FLCL fame was the real director of Diebuster, or as some call it, Gunbuster 2: Top Wo Nerae!), But both are incredible anime masterpieces. (I also need to see Royal Space Force: The Wings of Honnêamise so bad!) It's a lot of fun spotting the parallels between both shows. Just like Diebuster, I knew that 6 episodes was going to end pretty quickly for such a great show, so I like to spread the gap of time inbetween watching each volume to savor the experience and contemplate the ones I've just watched in the meantime. I'll get started on the last 2 episodes of the original soon enough.
"Too kawaii to live, too sugoi to die. Trapped in a moe~ existence"
User avatar
Skykid
Posts: 17655
Joined: Sun Nov 18, 2007 2:16 pm
Location: Planet Dust Asia

Re: Recommended Anime/Manga?

Post by Skykid »

Siren2011 wrote:(I also need to see Royal Space Force: The Wings of Honnêamise so bad!)
Oh yes you do.

I like the fact that Gunbuster draws so much influence from not only its own anime heritage, but from Top Gun and other similar stuff from the era. And isn't that the Chariots of Fire theme remixed during the training session in episode 1? Classic stuff. :)

It's funny though what a bit of soul and spirit (and gorgeous film grain you can only get from cels shot with a camera) can do for a plot that's essentially little girls in skimpy uniforms piloting mechs. It sounds like something they could have made in 2010, but somehow it's light years (literally!) ahead in terms of watchability
Always outnumbered, never outgunned - No zuo no die

User avatar
ryu
Posts: 2166
Joined: Mon May 31, 2010 6:43 pm
Contact:

Re: Recommended Anime/Manga?

Post by ryu »

gunbuster is crazy. i've only seen it myself just last year and, and absolutely thought it was a parody of the mecha genre the first few episodes in. and then it was not.

i think it's almost impossible to judge today, because it's too different from animation in the 2000s.

great show imo.
blog - scores - collection
Don't worry about it. You can travel from the Milky Way to Andromeda and back 1500 times before the sun explodes.
User avatar
xbl0x180
Posts: 2117
Joined: Mon Jul 04, 2011 5:28 pm

Re: Recommended Anime/Manga?

Post by xbl0x180 »

Skykid wrote:
Siren2011 wrote:(I also need to see Royal Space Force: The Wings of Honnêamise so bad!)
Oh yes you do.

I like the fact that Gunbuster draws so much influence from not only its own anime heritage, but from Top Gun and other similar stuff from the era. And isn't that the Chariots of Fire theme remixed during the training session in episode 1? Classic stuff. :)
You either have a R2 copy that was fan translated or you have a copy of the U.S. Renditions videotape. The "Chariots Of Fire" theme was censored out of the North American dvd release by Bandai for fear of copyright infringement (they didn't wanna pay royalties to Vangelis for its use).
It's funny though what a bit of soul and spirit (and gorgeous film grain you can only get from cels shot with a camera) can do for a plot that's essentially little girls in skimpy uniforms piloting mechs. It sounds like something they could have made in 2010, but somehow it's light years (literally!) ahead in terms of watchability
This was one of the few shows that sold me back in '92 into collecting anime (the three videocassettes were $35 each!). I thought the designs were quite faithful to Mikimoto Haruhiko's stills. Nothing GAINAX made after matched the detail quality of designs this show has.
User avatar
Siren2011
Banned User
Posts: 793
Joined: Sat Feb 12, 2011 6:51 pm
Location: The sky on my television set.

Re: Recommended Anime/Manga?

Post by Siren2011 »

:shock:
That was Vangelis?! Amazing. His COF score sounds so much different than his Blade Runner stuff.

Yup, I have the U.S. Renditions tape, and I noticed that song too.
It's funny though what a bit of soul and spirit (and gorgeous film grain you can only get from cels shot with a camera) can do for a plot that's essentially little girls in skimpy uniforms piloting mechs. It sounds like something they could have made in 2010, but somehow it's light years (literally!) ahead in terms of watchability
I have a bit of a fetish for that film grain.
"Too kawaii to live, too sugoi to die. Trapped in a moe~ existence"
User avatar
Siren2011
Banned User
Posts: 793
Joined: Sat Feb 12, 2011 6:51 pm
Location: The sky on my television set.

Re: Recommended Anime/Manga?

Post by Siren2011 »

:shock:
That was Vangelis?! Amazing. His COF score sounds so much different than his Blade Runner stuff.

Yup, I have the U.S. Renditions tape, and I noticed that song too.
It's funny though what a bit of soul and spirit (and gorgeous film grain you can only get from cels shot with a camera) can do for a plot that's essentially little girls in skimpy uniforms piloting mechs. It sounds like something they could have made in 2010, but somehow it's light years (literally!) ahead in terms of watchability
I have a bit of a fetish for that film grain.

EDIT: Just received Manie Manie in the mail. I'll give you guys all the juicy details when I get done with it.
"Too kawaii to live, too sugoi to die. Trapped in a moe~ existence"
User avatar
Obiwanshinobi
Posts: 7470
Joined: Sun Jul 26, 2009 1:14 am

Re: Recommended Anime/Manga?

Post by Obiwanshinobi »

Females operating high-tech machinery is hardly a contemporary fad. Airbats, Yamamoto Youko or AIKa are all fairly vintage now.
Come to think of it, Airbats not only has aged well graphically, but it's the first military-themed anime I'm watching since Seikai no... where the characters don't give me rash. For whatever reason anime about military dudes and ladies usually have Gundam-like, cringe-worthy characters (fabled Wings of Honneamise being no exception; luckily I watched it before the cult hype'd reached me - otherwise the reality check would've turned out nasty).
The rear gate is closed down
The way out is cut off

Image
User avatar
xbl0x180
Posts: 2117
Joined: Mon Jul 04, 2011 5:28 pm

Re: Recommended Anime/Manga?

Post by xbl0x180 »

Siren2011 wrote::shock:
That was Vangelis?! Amazing. His COF score sounds so much different than his Blade Runner stuff.

Yup, I have the U.S. Renditions tape, and I noticed that song too.
It's funny though what a bit of soul and spirit (and gorgeous film grain you can only get from cels shot with a camera) can do for a plot that's essentially little girls in skimpy uniforms piloting mechs. It sounds like something they could have made in 2010, but somehow it's light years (literally!) ahead in terms of watchability
I have a bit of a fetish for that film grain.

EDIT: Just received Manie Manie in the mail. I'll give you guys all the juicy details when I get done with it.
Well, Vangelis did the original Chariots Of Fire. The little ditty on episode 1 of Top Wo Nerae! was done by a separate music composer, but it was made to sound like it. Hence, Bandai Visual took it out for fear they'll get sued. For what they're charging for the dvd set (from 40-60 bucks!), they should've left the song intact. It's a good thing I kept my old vhs copies (now that I think about it... I blew over 100 bucks on them! :shock: ).

Streamline Pictures originally released "Neo-Tokyo" (Manie Manie Monogatari) back in 1993 or 1994. I still have a raggedy videocassette of it. I've seen that movie so many times that I get vertical roll and tracking problems on it. AD Vision re-released it on dvd later on. Kawajiri Yoshiaki's "The Running Man" was featured on MTV's second season of Liquid TV (around October 1992); I remember seeing it and I was blown away. Coincidentally, I had just finished watching Akira (another Streamline Pictures release). One major difference is that the MTV dub for "The Running Man" had a different narrator than the dub from Streamline Pictures.
PC Engine Fan X!
Posts: 9081
Joined: Wed Jan 26, 2005 10:32 pm

Re: Recommended Anime/Manga?

Post by PC Engine Fan X! »

I've noticed that the Bandai released USA region Akira Blu-Ray disc is based on the Streamline Pictures release version which has a couple of minor differences compared to the original unedited version of Akira (when doing a frame-by-frame analysis):

* The scene where Kaoru gets her t-shirt ripped off by some of Clown's thugs and she falls face first on the street, there's one single frame that was deleted of her nips shown just before she slams against the pavement. (In the original Japaneses theatrical version of Akira, it's present for completeness.)

* The scene of a huge & swollen Tetsuo slowly lumbering across inside the soccer stadium, his gentials are replaced with some cybernetic parts in the Streamline Pictures version of Akira (is present in the USA region Blu-ray version as well). In the original Japanese theatrical version, it's present & uncovered.

I understand that Streamline Pictures wanted to release Akira stateside in select cities back in 1990 but they could've released it unchanged and let Akira be as it is in it's unedited and unaltered form to preserve it's artistic integrity.

It's breathtaking and beautiful to view the Blu-Ray version of Akira in 1080p format indeed.

PC Engine Fan X! ^_~
User avatar
Skykid
Posts: 17655
Joined: Sun Nov 18, 2007 2:16 pm
Location: Planet Dust Asia

Re: Recommended Anime/Manga?

Post by Skykid »

xbl0x180 wrote: You either have a R2 copy that was fan translated or you have a copy of the U.S. Renditions videotape. The "Chariots Of Fire" theme was censored out of the North American dvd release by Bandai for fear of copyright infringement (they didn't wanna pay royalties to Vangelis for its use).
Ah must be the R2 one. It's actually a beautiful set, super quality, and came with all the extra science lessons and 3 short film segments based around the universe. I'd link you all to it but I'll probably get in trouble with the shmup feds, so PM me if you want it.

Just finished Gunbuster this morning and damn, that's what it's all about.
I can't believe it took me that long to actually watch something that awesome, I should have been onto that from the beginning (I knew of its existence of course.)

It was terrific. I was totally seduced by the beautiful colour and design work, and that incredible depth of imagination Anime had when they were all about exploring sci-fi.

SPOILERS:

The whole messing with Einstein's theory of relativity and light travel versus time was capitalised on beautifully. I'm not sure that the maths was always accurate, but it didn't matter because it was cemented so well into the storyline. And yes, this had what we would consider today as fairly trite themes: Young girls in skimpy clothing, a smattering of tits and ass, a hero who has to find her inner strength to prevail and become a hero of the ages, and lots of melodrama; yet it was still utterly captivating. All the influences were great (I was loving the product placement), and the SD science lessons were brilliant. I loved the fact that Gainax were bold enough to tell folks there was no episode 5 preview because "we haven't finished it yet", that Noriko has Miyazaki tributes on her wall and that they came up with a warp technology pioneered by prof 'Tanneuser' who developed the 'Tanneuser Gate', lol.

"I watched C-beams glitter in the dark near the Tannhauser gate." - Roy Batty, Blade Runner

And, I'm sure this has been mentioned in the past (but it was a new association for me), but does anyone see the quite obvious Gunbuster influence in MD Advanced Busterhawk Gleylancer? :)
I didn't really have both pieces of the puzzle until now, but Gleylancer is like Gunbuster the shmup that never was!

Closing: I don't care for the rose tinted glasses argument, yet I'm willing to accept that some of what I find beautiful about Anime was definitely crystallised in the Gunbuster era. That said, on the flip side, taking the 80's aura out of the frame, it's still more fun, with stronger characters, greater heart and a thousand times more artistry than the tin-canned factory pieces they churn out today. Someone show me something as good as Gunbuster that was made in the last decade and I'll eat my head.

EDIT: Getting Diebuster now.
Always outnumbered, never outgunned - No zuo no die

User avatar
xbl0x180
Posts: 2117
Joined: Mon Jul 04, 2011 5:28 pm

Re: Recommended Anime/Manga?

Post by xbl0x180 »

PC Engine Fan X! wrote:I've noticed that the Bandai released USA region Akira Blu-Ray disc is based on the Streamline Pictures release version which has a couple of minor differences compared to the original unedited version of Akira (when doing a frame-by-frame analysis):

* The scene where Kaoru gets her t-shirt ripped off by some of Clown's thugs and she falls face first on the street, there's one single frame that was deleted of her nips shown just before she slams against the pavement. (In the original Japaneses theatrical version of Akira, it's present for completeness.)

* The scene of a huge & swollen Tetsuo slowly lumbering across inside the soccer stadium, his gentials are replaced with some cybernetic parts in the Streamline Pictures version of Akira (is present in the USA region Blu-ray version as well). In the original Japanese theatrical version, it's present & uncovered.

I understand that Streamline Pictures wanted to release Akira stateside in select cities back in 1990 but they could've released it unchanged and let Akira be as it is in it's unedited and unaltered form to preserve it's artistic integrity.

It's breathtaking and beautiful to view the Blu-Ray version of Akira in 1080p format indeed.

PC Engine Fan X! ^_~
I have a dvd from Geneon, but I wouldn't know these differences since all I've had up to that point were the Streamline Pictures videocassette and the Orion videocassette. I should start saving up for this complete blu-ray version...
Skykid wrote:
xbl0x180 wrote: You either have a R2 copy that was fan translated or you have a copy of the U.S. Renditions videotape. The "Chariots Of Fire" theme was censored out of the North American dvd release by Bandai for fear of copyright infringement (they didn't wanna pay royalties to Vangelis for its use).
Ah must be the R2 one. It's actually a beautiful set, super quality, and came with all the extra science lessons and 3 short film segments based around the universe. I'd link you all to it but I'll probably get in trouble with the shmup feds, so PM me if you want it.

Just finished Gunbuster this morning and damn, that's what it's all about.
I can't believe it took me that long to actually watch something that awesome, I should have been onto that from the beginning (I knew of its existence of course.)

It was terrific. I was totally seduced by the beautiful colour and design work, and that incredible depth of imagination Anime had when they were all about exploring sci-fi.

SPOILERS:

The whole messing with Einstein's theory of relativity and light travel versus time was capitalised on beautifully. I'm not sure that the maths was always accurate, but it didn't matter because it was cemented so well into the storyline. And yes, this had what we would consider today as fairly trite themes: Young girls in skimpy clothing, a smattering of tits and ass, a hero who has to find her inner strength to prevail and become a hero of the ages, and lots of melodrama; yet it was still utterly captivating. All the influences were great (I was loving the product placement), and the SD science lessons were brilliant. I loved the fact that Gainax were bold enough to tell folks there was no episode 5 preview because "we haven't finished it yet", that Noriko has Miyazaki tributes on her wall and that they came up with a warp technology pioneered by prof 'Tanneuser' who developed the 'Tanneuser Gate', lol.

"I watched C-beams glitter in the dark near the Tannhauser gate." - Roy Batty, Blade Runner

And, I'm sure this has been mentioned in the past (but it was a new association for me), but does anyone see the quite obvious Gunbuster influence in MD Advanced Busterhawk Gleylancer? :)
I didn't really have both pieces of the puzzle until now, but Gleylancer is like Gunbuster the shmup that never was!

Closing: I don't care for the rose tinted glasses argument, yet I'm willing to accept that some of what I find beautiful about Anime was definitely crystallised in the Gunbuster era. That said, on the flip side, taking the 80's aura out of the frame, it's still more fun, with stronger characters, greater heart and a thousand times more artistry than the tin-canned factory pieces they churn out today. Someone show me something as good as Gunbuster that was made in the last decade and I'll eat my head.

EDIT: Getting Diebuster now.
Yes, there are girls in skimpy outfits who pilot big robots (although by looking at Jung, they're not little by any means). I was never that much opposed to those qualities in anime, so long as there is something else going on in the series: smart or raunchy comedy, imaginative sci-fi, memorable drama, killer action, etc. combined with distinctive chara designs and a decent music score to boot. Hell, only of these plot elements and movie qualities would be great, and Top Wo Nerae! has it all in spades.

Back in the late 80s and early 90s in North America, anime wasn't easy and cheep to come by, so it may be that some distributors took a lot more time filtering through the crap and bringing over the more significant works, stuff that had already proven to be great just a few years back. I think Oritsu Uchuugun: Oneamisu No Tsubasa/"Royal Space Force: The Wings Of Honneamise" benefited a little bit when Manga Video brought it over to the U.S. because no licensor would take a chance/invest on a losing movie if it also didn't happen to be one of the best movies ever made (on par with any top film) 8)

As far as recommending something as good as Top Wo Nerae!, I can't think of anything at the moment, except for a coupla series that came out in the early 2000s: Outlaw Star and Cowboy Bebop. Personally, I prefer Outlaw Star even if Cowboy Bebop had better designs, better music, and a more involving storyline; I found Outlaw Star to be a little more fast-paced and action-oriented, whereas there were a lot of slow parts in Cowboy Bebop.
Last edited by xbl0x180 on Sun Jul 31, 2011 8:34 pm, edited 1 time in total.
PC Engine Fan X!
Posts: 9081
Joined: Wed Jan 26, 2005 10:32 pm

Re: Recommended Anime/Manga?

Post by PC Engine Fan X! »

I recall back in 1988, there was a local Stockton-Modesto, CA chapter anime club called CFO - Cartoon Fanasty Organization. The regulars would meet up at a rented out room in Modesto that was inside a video rental store & show nothing but anime films and a few OVA series for six to eight hours straight. They had a bunch of CRT-based TV sets hooked up to VHS VCRs to record the cool Japanese dubbed VHS anime tapes brought in from the Los Angeles CFO chapter. I got to watch The Dagger of Kamui in it's entirety presented in Japanese. There was a CFO brochure with fan translations of the Kamui anime movie to keep tabs of what was being showing on-screen.

The local CFO chapters across the USA disbanded after it got easier to get anime in the early 1990s at retail and now the last remaining CFO club only shows anime based out of it's original stomping grounds.

The local Blockbuster store in Turlock, CA would have a huge anime rental selection due to it's proximity to the Stanislaus State University (aka UC Stanislaus nowdays) back in the early 1990s (considering that they catered to the hard-core otaku during that time). Even the video rental giant, Video Park, would rent out anime including the nortorious Legend of The Overfiend series.

This was before speciality stores like Suncoast Pictures even started selling anime back in the early 1990s. Yeah, it was crazy poning up $35-$40 for a Japanese language anime VHS tape bought from Suncoast back in those days.

Watching the Diebuster movie on Blu-Ray format is qiute breathtaking. Sure brings the Gunbuster: Aim for the Top! OVA prequel to a full closure. Kudos to Gainax for pulling it off successfully!

PC Engine Fan X! ^_~
User avatar
xbl0x180
Posts: 2117
Joined: Mon Jul 04, 2011 5:28 pm

Re: Recommended Anime/Manga?

Post by xbl0x180 »

In the early 90s, I'd rent videos from the local Tower Records in Tustin and El Toro (now a part of Lake Forest). I'd buy videos from either Comics Toons 'N Toys in Tustin or mail order from The Right Stuf, Intl. (actually, I still buy from TRSI). We also had a local chapter of an anime "society" at UC Irvine, which is where I'd get fan-subbed and untranslated stuff. UCI had a store that catered to importing Japanese videos, music, and books/magazines. I'd also spend a fortune at Kinokuniya in Costa Mesa. Lastly, there were also pen pals and groups one could join from looking at the back pages of the fanzines and by logging into the Internet through Prodigy (YEAH!). Getting part of a show in a month and paying $100 for it was considered "fast" and "cheap" :mrgreen:

The resources to get anime were there, but 1) it was all spread out across the city, county, state, or country, 2) it was expensive as hell, and 3) videocassettes sucked (they were large, tended to get damaged through normal use, would get eaten up by the vcr, etc.). Those are some of the things I DEFINITELY DON'T miss about the good ol' days [when Japanese cartoons were the best].

Speaking of good old days. I wish some of those old videos were officially re-released on dvd or blu-ray.

Dangaioh (U.S. Renditions)
Fantastic Adventure Of Yohko Leda (The Right Stuf, Intl.)
Genesis Survivor Gaiarth (AnimEigo)
Ningyo No Kizu/"Mermaid's Scar" (Viz Pictures)
Robot Carnival (Streamline Pictures)
Rumic World oavs (U.S. Manga Corps)
Shonan Bakusozoku (AnimEigo)
Space Adventure Cobra (Urban Vision)
Spirit Of Wonder (AnimEigo)
The Ultimate Teacher (U.S. Manga Corps)
Windaria (Streamline Pictures)
User avatar
Skykid
Posts: 17655
Joined: Sun Nov 18, 2007 2:16 pm
Location: Planet Dust Asia

Re: Recommended Anime/Manga?

Post by Skykid »

Always outnumbered, never outgunned - No zuo no die

User avatar
ryu
Posts: 2166
Joined: Mon May 31, 2010 6:43 pm
Contact:

Re: Recommended Anime/Manga?

Post by ryu »

that was my first impression as well, and i eventually really liked it. maybe just because i figured "wow it's really like gainax ripped themselves off with gurren lagann".

that aside, diebuster's plot will eventually take some corners you'd never expect. at least it's done things i've never seen in any other anime ever. might be worth the watch for just that.

iirc nono should be getting a lot less screentime too from episode 2 or 3 on. which everyone will probably agree with is a good thing.
blog - scores - collection
Don't worry about it. You can travel from the Milky Way to Andromeda and back 1500 times before the sun explodes.
User avatar
Skykid
Posts: 17655
Joined: Sun Nov 18, 2007 2:16 pm
Location: Planet Dust Asia

Re: Recommended Anime/Manga?

Post by Skykid »

ryu wrote:that was my first impression as well, and i eventually really liked it. maybe just because i figured "wow it's really like gainax ripped themselves off with gurren lagann".

that aside, diebuster's plot will eventually take some corners you'd never expect. at least it's done things i've never seen in any other anime ever. might be worth the watch for just that.

iirc nono should be getting a lot less screentime too from episode 2 or 3 on. which everyone will probably agree with is a good thing.
Yes but... Isn't she the main character? :|

I'll watch ep2 tomorrow but really, I think I've seen plenty enough already. I can't see any show that opens like that ever getting close to the magic in Gunbuster.
Always outnumbered, never outgunned - No zuo no die

User avatar
Ebbo
Posts: 463
Joined: Thu Sep 10, 2009 1:25 pm
Location: Finland

Re: Recommended Anime/Manga?

Post by Ebbo »

I can say the first three episodes feel kind of pointless but the last episodes are quite stunning. Maybe not as much as Gunbuster's finale but in the end Diebuster managed to redeem itself atleast in my eyes and even ties up to the original series quite nicely.
User avatar
greg
Posts: 1854
Joined: Wed Jan 26, 2005 4:10 am
Location: Gunma-ken, Japan
Contact:

Re: Recommended Anime/Manga?

Post by greg »

Guys, I picked up Gunbuster on UMD for REAL LOW CHEAP on my last trip to Japan, and watched it on my PSP for the flight home. I'd never seen Gunbuster before then. Apparently they edited the episodes into one movie, right? I haven't seen Gunbuster in its entirety via episodes, but I have seen enough of it to notice that they took a lot of the footage out. I especially noticed the "Rocky"-style training sequences were reduced to almost nothing. Has anyone seen this movie version?
Image
Undamned is the leading English-speaking expert on the consolized UD-CPS2 because he's the one who made it.
User avatar
Skykid
Posts: 17655
Joined: Sun Nov 18, 2007 2:16 pm
Location: Planet Dust Asia

Re: Recommended Anime/Manga?

Post by Skykid »

greg wrote:Guys, I picked up Gunbuster on UMD for REAL LOW CHEAP on my last trip to Japan, and watched it on my PSP for the flight home. I'd never seen Gunbuster before then. Apparently they edited the episodes into one movie, right? I haven't seen Gunbuster in its entirety via episodes, but I have seen enough of it to notice that they took a lot of the footage out. I especially noticed the "Rocky"-style training sequences were reduced to almost nothing. Has anyone seen this movie version?
If it's an anime of some note, I would always recommend watching the OVA formats first - the condensed movies always lose something and feel slightly weird.

Also, the training sequence was cut from all DVD releases, OVA or movie due to fear of copyright infringement of Vangelis' Chariots of Fire theme. They even replaced the track and dropped the audio quality of the entire first episode, angering fans (apparently.)

You got a PM incoming though. :wink:
Always outnumbered, never outgunned - No zuo no die

User avatar
greg
Posts: 1854
Joined: Wed Jan 26, 2005 4:10 am
Location: Gunma-ken, Japan
Contact:

Re: Recommended Anime/Manga?

Post by greg »

Skykid wrote:Also, the training sequence was cut from all DVD releases, OVA or movie due to fear of copyright infringement of Vangelis' Chariots of Fire theme. They even replaced the track and dropped the audio quality of the entire first episode, angering fans (apparently.)
Yeah, back in the 80s, Japan didn't have to worry about much anime being exported out of their country in an official way. That's a shame that they simply removed those scenes from all DVD releases. They should've at least just inserted some other music that fit those scenes. Heck, maybe even the "Gonna Fly Now" song from the Rocky movies. ;)

As for the link you sent me, my work's content filter blocked it, so I'll have to look at it when I get home.
Image
Undamned is the leading English-speaking expert on the consolized UD-CPS2 because he's the one who made it.
User avatar
xbl0x180
Posts: 2117
Joined: Mon Jul 04, 2011 5:28 pm

Re: Recommended Anime/Manga?

Post by xbl0x180 »

greg wrote:
Skykid wrote:Also, the training sequence was cut from all DVD releases, OVA or movie due to fear of copyright infringement of Vangelis' Chariots of Fire theme. They even replaced the track and dropped the audio quality of the entire first episode, angering fans (apparently.)
Yeah, back in the 80s, Japan didn't have to worry about much anime being exported out of their country in an official way. That's a shame that they simply removed those scenes from all DVD releases. They should've at least just inserted some other music that fit those scenes. Heck, maybe even the "Gonna Fly Now" song from the Rocky movies. ;)

As for the link you sent me, my work's content filter blocked it, so I'll have to look at it when I get home.
Oh, don't worry about that. Japanese R2 releases usually have those scenes intact. It's the North American, European, and Australian versions that get censored and edited. The training sequence with the "Chariots Of Fire" sound-alike is still there, but Bandai re-synched generic background music from another part of the show (it did affect the sound quality of the dvd transfer for the first episode). The Japanese Region 2 dvd and blu-ray should have this scene with the original music.

This same thing happened with Maison Ikkoku. The Japanese crew loved two of Gilbert O'Sullivan's songs (his famous 70s hit is "Alone Again (Naturally)" ) and they put it on the credits of one episode. They never cleared the rights, so they had to change the theme song again for the rest of the episodes, although episode 24 [in Japan] STILL has Gilbert O'Sullivan's songs - whereas in the U.S., Viz changed the theme (Viz is known for doing crazy, inexplicable edits and cuts to their anime and manga releases). This same thing happened again with Duran Duran's "Girls On Film" being used as the theme song to the televised version of Speed Grapher. The royalties Duran Duran would command isn't something any anime distributor could afford, so they had to change it for the video release (suffice to say, I won't be getting the video release without the original theme song) 8)

Maison Ikkoku
User avatar
greg
Posts: 1854
Joined: Wed Jan 26, 2005 4:10 am
Location: Gunma-ken, Japan
Contact:

Re: Recommended Anime/Manga?

Post by greg »

Well, the Gunbuster UMD I bought was a Japanese release, so those training scenes were just taken out to shrink it into a movie.

As for the Region 1 release of the DVD, you're telling me that those scenes are there, but just have some different music edited in? I wouldn't mind that. Just as long as they don't cut away the animation.
Image
Undamned is the leading English-speaking expert on the consolized UD-CPS2 because he's the one who made it.
User avatar
Skykid
Posts: 17655
Joined: Sun Nov 18, 2007 2:16 pm
Location: Planet Dust Asia

Re: Recommended Anime/Manga?

Post by Skykid »

greg wrote:Well, the Gunbuster UMD I bought was a Japanese release, so those training scenes were just taken out to shrink it into a movie.

As for the Region 1 release of the DVD, you're telling me that those scenes are there, but just have some different music edited in? I wouldn't mind that. Just as long as they don't cut away the animation.
Yo didn't you check your inbox?
Always outnumbered, never outgunned - No zuo no die

User avatar
greg
Posts: 1854
Joined: Wed Jan 26, 2005 4:10 am
Location: Gunma-ken, Japan
Contact:

Re: Recommended Anime/Manga?

Post by greg »

Skykid wrote:Yo didn't you check your inbox?
I did, actually. I've just been busy lately. I just started teaching another ESL class at night. I intend to aquire the full Gunbuster show on DVD. I just picked up the movie on UMD because it was only about 600 yen, and it gave me something to watch on the airplane back to the USA.
Image
Undamned is the leading English-speaking expert on the consolized UD-CPS2 because he's the one who made it.
User avatar
Siren2011
Banned User
Posts: 793
Joined: Sat Feb 12, 2011 6:51 pm
Location: The sky on my television set.

Re: Recommended Anime/Manga?

Post by Siren2011 »

So I just got done watching Neo Tokyo.

My feelings about it are mixed.

It is clear that the labyrinth bit was meant to be a background to the other two stories, but it lacked a tangible story itself, thus was boring as fuck. It tried desperately to be avant garde, but it came across as pretentious and nonsensical. I loved the bit with Gymnopédie No. 1, though.

THE RUNNING MAN

Ok, so I really didn't like this one, either. While watching the cars explode was fascinating, and that one guy's expression will be etched into my brain for years to come, they really didn't focus on the details of the story, but instead relied on showing the viewer with visuals alone. The only things we knew about the main character was the fact that he was going insane from his dedication, and that he was a champion racer. They didn't bother to expand the story at all. This led for quite a lackluster watch. If I wanted to watch "abstract art", I would have gone to a museum of modern art (which I would never do). It still looked cool, though, despite the moments where basically nothing interesting happened. Better looking than the circus one with the boy and his cat, anyway.

CONSTRUCTION CANCELATION ORDER

This is where the movie shines, right here! The first three minutes I was like "ah, it'll just be like the other two," but that was definitely not the case I would soon find out. The relationship between the supervisor and the worker robot is priceless, and the jokes that occur between them are hilarious (Feeding the guy nuts and bolts, telling him it was no longer obligated to work for him, etc). Just watching the supervisor's insanity unfold was reason enough to watch Neo Tokyo, especially if you've ever been frustrated with electronics before. The only thing I hated about this one was that it was over_WAY_ TOO_SOON. What the FUCK were they thinking? This perfectly compelling concept could have been milked for at least 30 more minutes, as long as the jokes were fresh. Out of all three "sub cartoons", it was by far the best animated one and the one with the most inspired art direction (very impressive for something that was made four years before my birth!).

Overall, it's a watch for me. But I advise anyone who hasn't seen this film to skip over the first two "features". You would literally be missing nothing.
"Too kawaii to live, too sugoi to die. Trapped in a moe~ existence"
User avatar
xbl0x180
Posts: 2117
Joined: Mon Jul 04, 2011 5:28 pm

Re: Recommended Anime/Manga?

Post by xbl0x180 »

greg wrote:Well, the Gunbuster UMD I bought was a Japanese release, so those training scenes were just taken out to shrink it into a movie.

As for the Region 1 release of the DVD, you're telling me that those scenes are there, but just have some different music edited in? I wouldn't mind that. Just as long as they don't cut away the animation.
I think the training scene was left intact, except they changed the music. When bandai visual changed the music, they also screwed up the sound for the entire first episode (it is said to sound a little bit "muffled"). Most normal viewers will not notice the change.

What's funny is that I think the bath scene has a little more censorship than I thought. Jung's, um, down there seems to be kinda, um, fogged (not mosaic, but more like a smudge down there). Hahah :P
User avatar
Hagane
Posts: 1666
Joined: Mon May 02, 2011 2:12 am
Location: Buenos Aires, Argentina

Re: Recommended Anime/Manga?

Post by Hagane »

Blade of the Immortal volume 27 is the fucking greatest thing in an action manga ever. And I don't even read moonspeak to know what the characters were talking about! Samura is just so great at action scenes.

Also happy to see that Vinland Saga is slowly getting out of its Harvest Moon in the Middle Ages phase. Anyone who didn't read it should do that right now.
User avatar
Skykid
Posts: 17655
Joined: Sun Nov 18, 2007 2:16 pm
Location: Planet Dust Asia

Re: Recommended Anime/Manga?

Post by Skykid »

Hagane wrote:Blade of the Immortal volume 27 is the fucking greatest thing in an action manga ever. And I don't even read moonspeak to know what the characters were talking about! Samura is just so great at action scenes.
Where is that in the Dark Horse localisation volumes? I'm up to 21 here.
And yes, I've been trying to get people to realise BOI is the fucking greatest thing in action manga ever for a while. :)
Siren2011 wrote:So I just got done watching Neo Tokyo.

My feelings about it are mixed.

It is clear that the labyrinth bit was meant to be a background to the other two stories, but it lacked a tangible story itself, thus was boring as fuck. It tried desperately to be avant garde, but it came across as pretentious and nonsensical. I loved the bit with Gymnopédie No. 1, though.

THE RUNNING MAN

Ok, so I really didn't like this one, either. While watching the cars explode was fascinating, and that one guy's expression will be etched into my brain for years to come, they really didn't focus on the details of the story, but instead relied on showing the viewer with visuals alone. The only things we knew about the main character was the fact that he was going insane from his dedication, and that he was a champion racer. They didn't bother to expand the story at all. This led for quite a lackluster watch. If I wanted to watch "abstract art", I would have gone to a museum of modern art (which I would never do). It still looked cool, though, despite the moments where basically nothing interesting happened. Better looking than the circus one with the boy and his cat, anyway.

CONSTRUCTION CANCELATION ORDER

This is where the movie shines, right here! The first three minutes I was like "ah, it'll just be like the other two," but that was definitely not the case I would soon find out. The relationship between the supervisor and the worker robot is priceless, and the jokes that occur between them are hilarious (Feeding the guy nuts and bolts, telling him it was no longer obligated to work for him, etc). Just watching the supervisor's insanity unfold was reason enough to watch Neo Tokyo, especially if you've ever been frustrated with electronics before. The only thing I hated about this one was that it was over_WAY_ TOO_SOON. What the FUCK were they thinking? This perfectly compelling concept could have been milked for at least 30 more minutes, as long as the jokes were fresh. Out of all three "sub cartoons", it was by far the best animated one and the one with the most inspired art direction (very impressive for something that was made four years before my birth!).

Overall, it's a watch for me. But I advise anyone who hasn't seen this film to skip over the first two "features". You would literally be missing nothing.

An accurate appraisal. Although I didn't dislike The Running Man (I liked its darkness and its theme) I would agree the first two are not must-sees.
That said, there is an impressive level of artistry in Labyrinth, the problem is it stuns you as the first in the pack because you're not expecting that kind of short from a DVD called 'Neo Tokyo'. Including that as an opener is an error in my book, but if you go back to it a second time knowing what to expect and take it on its own merits, it's quite a good - if 'arty' - little film.

But Construction Cancellation Order far eclipses anything on the disc. It's probably my favourite anime short ever, exhibiting the best qualities of Japan's dark sci-fi. Like you said, the only problem is you could have watched it for 45 minutes easy, and wanted it to go on. Even at just 18 minutes though, it's a pretty priceless Otomo piece: blackly humorous, hugely atmospheric and filled with dread.
Always outnumbered, never outgunned - No zuo no die

User avatar
Hagane
Posts: 1666
Joined: Mon May 02, 2011 2:12 am
Location: Buenos Aires, Argentina

Re: Recommended Anime/Manga?

Post by Hagane »

Skykid wrote: Where is that in the Dark Horse localisation volumes? I'm up to 21 here.
And yes, I've been trying to get people to realise BOI is the fucking greatest thing in action manga ever for a while. :)
Glénat (Spanish/French publisher) is at volume 26, about to release 27. I've dl'd 27 in Japanese though, I just couldn't wait.

If you like BOTI you should check out Vinland Saga if you haven't already! Excellent action manga about Vikings punching horses and other amazingly manly stuff! By Makoto Yukimura (Planetes).
Post Reply