I've been away for some time. I'm currently working on a small utility to save scores for older console games. This is slightly better than pencil and paper because it is harder to misplace a computer. The end product will support Windows, Mac OS, and Linux. This is mostly for myself, I know old console support is hit and miss around here. This is good for games such as Star Solder which do not support saving.
Somebody will probably do a better version but I will share my utility for free when I finish. I like to have a sort of database for my scores rather than 200 little random sheets of paper.
The score format will be limited it is not good for modern shmups.
Format
Name - Score - Level - Info
The info selection will be a short user defined section that will show as a tool tip when the score is hovered over. This can be anything.
Example Info
(Star Soldier)
"Finally destroyed both eyes at the end of the level for 80,000 pts!"
(Qix)
"Destroyed Qix with a HUGE 90% area claim on the first level"
Screen capture:

So take it or leave it, this is mostly for my use.