I loved the Neo Geo since the nearby corner store got Cyber-Lip. I popped in way more quarters than someone of my limited reflexes should ever have spent banging my head against the digital wall that is Magician Lord. I was down with Fatal Fury from jump. For the second half of the 90s, King of Fighters was practically my life. I don't think I've ever owned a console from gen 5 onward without a KoF port (unless it literally didn't get one - Wii U , wai?). I was an early adopter - as it would turn out, the only kind of adopter it would have - of the Neo Geo Pocket Color. So when I finally had the discretionary income to go after a real AES, I was so excited.
Except I hardly ever played it. It's like, one of the worst ways to play those games now. I had really thought the AES versions would have...just a lot
more to them. Limited or no options, no practice modes, save states, no rapid fire without an ASCII stick, or even button remapping. It was that last bit that did it. I was so pumped to plow through Pulstar on real hardware, but without being able to map charge + rapid shot to different buttons it was a notably worse experience, I just kept thinking "Why am I not playing the ACA version instead?"
The other thing was the packaging. SNK fighters are drowning in lore and background connections between the fighters, I just erroneously assumed there was some way for people who actually owned the games to know what that was. But nope, even though SNK seemingly just repurposed the same game cases the PC 88/9801 scene was using, whose publishers
filled them with absurd amounts of fan materials, all Neo Geo owners get is a bog-standard instruction book. Doesn't matter if you paid $300 for your shiny new cartridge, you want details? Want to know why Iori is the saxophone player in an evil S&M jazz band? Go track down some obscure Hong Kong manhua that you can't read to get the rest of the story, printing that stuff up would add $6 to the packaging cost. We're not running a charity here.
I sold my Neo Geo back in October, and haven't thought about it twice since then. The best part of owning a Neo Geo by far was being able to say that I owned a Neo Geo. Except I promptly discovered almost nobody IRL even knows what that is. Even gamers who know what KoF is or know Terry Bogard from various media have only the vaguest of ideas. Even most gamers who played these games in the wild have no understanding of them being part of a larger ecosystem.
If Neo Geo ownership makes you happy, I totally get it. I have tons of Saturn & PC Engine & Mega Drive & Super Famicom games on my shelves, so I fully expected to be over the moon with it. But I just found that the NG scene involves too much expense for too little return for me. Spending thousands to have a worse time playing Aero Fighters 3 than someone who just spent $50 on Sonic Wings Special for the Saturn - or $10 for AF3 on ACA - isn't the kind of rap game Liberace tax bracket I'm in.