cicada88 wrote:Mortificator wrote:Ajora wrote:The PC Engine Bomberman titles are much, much better than any of the Super Famicom titles. Bomberman 93 and 94 are must plays.
Plain old PCE Bomberman is typical of the tedium this series consisted of for almost the first decade of its existence. Campaign is unremarkable rectangle after unremarkable rectangle with only a single boss. Battle mode only has one stage and basic power-ups.
'93 is the first Bomberman to approach competence, and '94 is the first to reach greatness and make last year's girl completely obsolete. The only SNES game on par with '94 is Super Bomberman 2. Super Bomberman 5 can match that pair in battle mode, but not campaign. The other Super games are lower in quality, though only SB3 falls below '93.
i.e. This Ranking?:
- Saturn Bomberman (SS)
- Bomberman '94 (PCE)
- Super Bomberman 2 (SFC)
- Super Bomberman 5 (SFC)
----THRESHOLD-OF-GREATNESS----
- Super Bomberman 4 (SFC)
- Super Bomberman (SFC)
- Bomberman '93 (PCE)
----THRESHOLD-OF-COMPETENCE----
- Super Bomberman 3 (SFC)
- Bomberman (PCE)
Discuss.
If I consider campaign and battle mode separately...
5-star battle modes
Bomberman '94
Super Bomberman 2
Super Bomberman 5
Saturn Bomberman
Bomberman Generation
Bomberman Jetters Game Collection
Bomberman Story DS
Bomberman Land Touch 2
Bomberman 2 [DS]
4-star battle modes
Super Bomberman
Super Bomberman 4
Bomberman 64
Saturn Bomberman Fight
Bomberman Party Edition
Bomberman Tournament
Bomberman Live
3-star battle modes
Bomberman '93
Bomberman GB 2
Super Bomberman 3
Bomberman Jetters Densetsu
Bomberman Jetters [GC]
Bomberman Land [PSP]
Bomberman Live Battlefest
2-star battle modes
Atomic Bomberman
Bomberman World [PS1]
Bomberman 64: The Second Attack
Bomberman Online [Dreamcast]
Bomberman Online International
Bomberman [DS]
Bomberman [PSP]
Bomberman Act Zero
Bomberman Land Touch
Bomberman Land [Wii]
Bomberman Blast
1-star battle modes
Bomber Boy
Bomberman [PCE]
Bomberman [arcade]
Bomberman World [arcade]
Bomberman II [NES]
Bomberman GB
Neo Bomberman
Bomberman Quest
This is without taking online play into consideration; the ones that supported it would probably be a tier higher when it was active. Oh, and I'm not implying anything by the order within a tier.
5-star campaigns
Bomberman '94
Super Bomberman 2
Saturn Bomberman
Bomberman GB 3
Bomberman 64: The Second Attack
Bomberman 2 [DS]
4-star campaigns
Bomberman GB 2
Bomberman 64
Super Bomberman 5
Bomberman Quest
Bomberman Tournament
Bomberman Generation
3-star campaigns
Bomberman [arcade]
Bomberman World [arcade]
Bomberman '93
Super Bomberman
Super Bomberman 4
Bomberman World [PS1]
Bomberman Max
Bomberman Jetters Densetsu
Sentai Bombermen
2-star campaigns
Bomber Boy
Bomberman [PCE]
Super Bomberman 3
Saturn Bomberman Fight
Neo Bomberman
Bomberman Online [Dreamcast]
Bomberman Max 2
Bomberman Jetters [GC]
Bomberman [DS]
Bomberman [PSP]
1-star campaigns
Bomberman [MSX]
3-D Bomberman
Bomberman [NES]
Bomberman II [NES]
Bomberman GB
Atomic Bomberman
Bomberman Party Edition
Bomberman Act Zero
Bomberman Story DS
I say "campaign," but what I really mean is any dedicated singleplayer or co-op modes with traditional Bomberman gameplay. That includes stuff like Saturn's master game and GB 3's caravan modes.