Zen wrote:Skykid wrote:I'm just gonna say, while on the subject, I did a full report on Rogue One in the RO thread, and if we're looking for a film that fails almost primarily due to lack of charisma and personality in its cast, that is the movie for analyses.
Modern movies have really lost a simple aspect of the art when it comes to developing characters. They just don't know how to do it anymore.
(Have not seen
Rogue One yet, so I have not read your review) and while we all seem, to some degree, to perhaps be talking about different things over the last posts, your point;
"Modern movies have really lost a simple aspect of the art when it comes to developing characters. They just don't know how to do it anymore." is well taken.
Do you have a theory as to why this, or is it just an observation? Does this perhaps tie into points being brought up about persona versus acting ability? Is more neutral or homogenised character writing a fashion/sign of the times or, are there really no more heroes?
Yes, I have theories. To me it's a general failure on an industry level that's fettered down to the product through producer systems. Ultimately it's about priorities. There was a time when, believe it or not, producers actually thought a good movie had a better chance of making their investment worthwhile. Doesn't mean they had a clue what constituted a good movie, but under the circumstances the director had a little more free reign and trust in Hollywood.
Now the producers make the movie by way of a blueprint. There is a modern template that doesn't call for well written, acted, or three dimensional characters - it calls for bigger and louder effects to divert the audience's attention from the absent core. The idea of engaging on a simple emotional level with a protagonist is not as important as getting the cast out the way and home (ending their salary) so post production can begin to apply all the spectacular background stuff.
The problem is human beings don't care about background stuff no matter how spectacular it gets. We want emotional engagement with other human beings who are against the odds and/or within a drama. That's why modern Hollywood is so stone cold. They place no emphasis on rounding personalities, only on moulding a poorly written half-baked script in thrilling CGI.
I think what we're witnessing is modern tools making people, characters and personalities less essential. The template is an absolutely robust money making machine and they have no intention of adjusting it if it ain't broke and people like xxx1993 keep going to watch every piece of shiny shit they spew out of their industrial asses with a kind of brainded relish.
You can probably blame the human race, in part, for becoming progressively stupider in the internet age, and consuming absolute crap as part of their daily diet.
"I can't miss Resident Evil: The Final Chapter, I hear it's the best one yet!"
And on a final note, I'd like to add something less bleak. Hollywood hasn't always been this broken. American Zoetrope lit it on fire in the 70s and 80s: the trio of Coppola, Lucas and Spielberg, and other directors caught wind of the motion and went to town, creating all the material that has been under the Hollywood remake/reboot process for the last decade.
But with the exception of a few efforts, Hollywood isn't about art films, but it was about artistry of film to a degree. What we used to get were well made films with simplistic, comic book, cliché characters. And there's nothing wrong with comic book, cliché characters - they're the ones we can identify with on a basic level and foster an easy emotional engagement.
Doctor Jones, Arnie, Marty McFly, Rambo, Captain Willard, Murphy, Lieutenant Ripley, Chief Brody, to name some of the more famous ones, weren't exactly realistic characters - but they were personable, humorous, lively characters.
Fast forward to 2017 and we have Felicity Jones in Rogue One: a gender neutral, expression free lump of coal that looks like a water doused cat for the duration. No humour, no memorable dialogue, no weight or gravity, no depth or complexity, not even a simple personality quirk to identify with.
This shit is dire. I'd love to will the entire world to stop paying for it, but they're not listening. Nicki Minaj is busy shitting in their ears and they're having a great time bobbing their heads.