Metal Slug a shmup? Wikipedia thinks so.
Metal Slug a shmup? Wikipedia thinks so.
I just noticed that Wikipedia has Metal Slug classified as a shoot 'em up (link). They make no mention of it being part of the run 'n gun contra clones like most reviewers make it out to be.
And I agree. Metal Slug has a total different look & feel than Contra. And it shouldn't be excluded because part of the game is played by a character on foot - shmup vehicals are there, you just have to find them. And I think that if Metal Slug came out before Contra, it would have been added to our shmup lists right next to classics like Gradius & R-type.
And I agree. Metal Slug has a total different look & feel than Contra. And it shouldn't be excluded because part of the game is played by a character on foot - shmup vehicals are there, you just have to find them. And I think that if Metal Slug came out before Contra, it would have been added to our shmup lists right next to classics like Gradius & R-type.
-
crithit5000
- Posts: 925
- Joined: Thu Jan 27, 2005 3:17 am
- Location: Youngstown OH, USA
- Contact:
-
superhitachi4
- Posts: 379
- Joined: Thu Apr 14, 2005 11:30 pm
- Location: RLC Jr.
From what I read in wiki, they called it a shoot 'em up, and not a shmup. I'm cool if someone calls it that and not a shmup.
I'm really picking hairs with that one, but that's just what I think. I'd rather call it a run 'n gunner, though.
In other wiki business, I created an Alien Soldier article a few weeks ago in early December with two sentences, now it's a big ole article. Some asshat added its rarity is on par with Gunstar Heroes, though, bah. Pretty neat to think it grew so quickly, though. Even pics are in there.
I'm really picking hairs with that one, but that's just what I think. I'd rather call it a run 'n gunner, though.
In other wiki business, I created an Alien Soldier article a few weeks ago in early December with two sentences, now it's a big ole article. Some asshat added its rarity is on par with Gunstar Heroes, though, bah. Pretty neat to think it grew so quickly, though. Even pics are in there.
-
Guardians Knight
- Posts: 502
- Joined: Tue Jan 25, 2005 10:15 pm
- Location: England
There's lots of instances of ship to ship combat in Metal Slug. Here's a nice picture gallery of Metal Slug 3 from start to finish.extrarice wrote:I vote no, but I'm leaning towards some sort of hybrid. It's primarily a Contra-style run-n-gun, but far more frantic, and there's vehicles. But, from what I've played, it's missing ship-to-ship combat typically found in shmups.
http://spoonman.roarvgm.com/neogeo/ms3gallery/hi.htm
At one point, it even becomes a vertical shooter.
Yea, Metal Slug is no shmup. Its not about vehicular combat, as theres plenty of shmups where you just play as people. I think to be a real shmup you need forced scrolling and no limit on movement(I.E. no gravity). And even if it were about vehicular combat, vehicles may be featured, but the amount of onfoot action outweighs vehicular combat, and we don't assign genres based upon the minority of gameplay time(why don't we call Mario Party a racing game since it has a few racing minigames?). Sure there are segments of Metal Slug that strongly resemble hori. and vert. shmups, but they are not the norm throughout the game, the onfoot action platformer gameplay is. Therefore, as others have said, Metal Slug is an action platformer, or what some call a "run n' gun" game just as contra is. Metal Slug isn't even really more "manic" or "far more frantic" than Contra as one person said, as anybody who has played an actual arcade Contra knows they are diffinently on the more hardcore end the genre spectrum. As a friend of mine once said, "Everybody says they love contra... until they play it."
-
BulletMagnet
- Posts: 13901
- Joined: Wed Jan 26, 2005 4:05 am
- Location: Wherever.
- Contact:
-
cigsthecat
- Posts: 929
- Joined: Wed Jan 26, 2005 12:35 am
- Location: Burbank, CA
I believe that it was coined by the press in the early 80's as a way to describe the space shooters that were popular in the acades at the time. Here's some early 80's shoot 'em ups.Ganelon wrote:To me, Metal Slug = sidescroller
Somebody should find the Brit who came up with the term "shmup" or whoever first coined the phrase "shoot 'em up" and have him say what he meant by the term.
Space Invaders
Galaxians
Galaga
Gorf
Phoenix
Xevious
Defender
Stargate
Moon Patrol
Scramble
Vanguard
Berzerk
Robotron
Asteroids
Zaxxon
And rumor has it that the acnonym "shmup" was first used by the editors of Zzap!64 (a C64 mag) which was first published in 1985.
Well.... by the old definition, Metal Slug (and even Contra for that matter) would be classified as a shoot 'em up. Metal Slug is just a combination of Defender & Robotron, with a bit of Moon Patrol tossed in.
Oh... guess what? Contra Hard Corps is included in our own xenocide files. Link. I guess that it was so good on the Genesis that it got annexed.
Oh yea... "shmup" doesnt seem to roll of the tongue at allsubcons wrote:Yeah, but gun rhymes with run.oNyx wrote:Its a... jump'n'shoot. "Run'n'gun" is silly, because there isn't a run button (usually)
It has to roll off the tongue. Think man!
So... super mario bros and castlevania are shooters, because you can shoot stuff? Oh and ocarina of time and beyond good and evil then, too. Oh and wipeout and mariokart :>Seven Force wrote:As far as I'm concerned, if you shoot stuff, it can be called a "Shooter".
There is a run-modifier button in mario bros. Well, you are running all the time, but in game terms its walking. Just look at doom... running there means flying with about 80 km/h.Seven Force wrote:Yes there is. Hold right to run.oNyx wrote:Its a... jump'n'shoot. "Run'n'gun" is silly, because there isn't a run button (usually)
-
professor ganson
- Posts: 5163
- Joined: Mon Feb 21, 2005 3:59 am
- Location: OHIO
Metal Slug and Contra are 2D shooters, but I think it is against ordinary usage to call them shmups.
To my mind there are two ordinary uses of the term "shmup."
1. A not-so-inclusive use.
2. An inclusive use.
Shmups are usually defined by reference to paradigm/exemplary cases. We say: "Shmups are games like Gradius, R-Type, and DoDonPachi." With the not-so-inclusive use, we are very strict about how similar the games must be to the paradigm cases. On this usage we do not allow even Robotron, Galaga, Space Invaders or Defender.
With the inclusive use of the term "shmup" we are less strict about how similar the games have to be to Gradius and R-Type. Indeed, on this more flexible use, we might even include Galaga and Space Invaders among the paradigm cases. This is the use that we employ when we have our Top 25 lists each year.
It seems to me that one could use the term "shmup" in an EVEN WIDER sense, and include Contra and Metal Slug. But this is NOT the ordinary usage. Why? Because "shmup" does not mean just 2D shooter. The term "shmup" is defined by reference to paradigm cases. Contra and Metal Slug just are very different from Gradius and R-Type.
To my mind there are two ordinary uses of the term "shmup."
1. A not-so-inclusive use.
2. An inclusive use.
Shmups are usually defined by reference to paradigm/exemplary cases. We say: "Shmups are games like Gradius, R-Type, and DoDonPachi." With the not-so-inclusive use, we are very strict about how similar the games must be to the paradigm cases. On this usage we do not allow even Robotron, Galaga, Space Invaders or Defender.
With the inclusive use of the term "shmup" we are less strict about how similar the games have to be to Gradius and R-Type. Indeed, on this more flexible use, we might even include Galaga and Space Invaders among the paradigm cases. This is the use that we employ when we have our Top 25 lists each year.
It seems to me that one could use the term "shmup" in an EVEN WIDER sense, and include Contra and Metal Slug. But this is NOT the ordinary usage. Why? Because "shmup" does not mean just 2D shooter. The term "shmup" is defined by reference to paradigm cases. Contra and Metal Slug just are very different from Gradius and R-Type.
Then what about The Guardian Legend? It's half vertical-scroller shmup, half Alien Syndrome overhead-puzzle-shooter-space-action.J-Manic wrote:Nope. I consider the Metal Slug series to be an action platformer, just like the Mega Man series. You're not supposed to be able jump in a shmup. If you can do more than just shoot, bomb and dodge bullets, then it is not a shmup. Shmups and action platformers are two different kinds of genres.
http://www.classicgaming.com/shmups/guardianlegend/
(off-topic, I know)
I consider Metal Slug a Run-n-Gun the same way i think Shock Troopers and Ninja Commando are Run-n-Guns. I still think Shmup's are pretty much coined on whether you have a flying ship of some sort and not characters running and shooting on the ground...but thats just my opinion.
"ooh, ahh, thats how all this starts, but then theres running and screaming" -LW:Jurrassic Park-
A bunch of games that aren't recognized as shmups are - I think Smash TV is in there too.Alpolio wrote:Oh... guess what? Contra Hard Corps is included in our own xenocide files. Link. I guess that it was so good on the Genesis that it got annexed.
I think shmup is a stupid phrase anyway. I feel embarassed saying it. I just say shooter and lump everything in there. I don't want to seem like some genre purist.
What about Guwange? They are running and shooting on the ground in that.Sundance wrote:I consider Metal Slug a Run-n-Gun the same way i think Shock Troopers and Ninja Commando are Run-n-Guns. I still think Shmup's are pretty much coined on whether you have a flying ship of some sort and not characters running and shooting on the ground...but thats just my opinion.