4th Annual Top 25 Shmups of All Time! - Polls Closed

This is the main shmups forum. Chat about shmups in here - keep it on-topic please!
User avatar
Zach Keene
Posts: 1059
Joined: Tue Jan 25, 2005 10:38 pm
Location: Flenceburg
Contact:

4th Annual Top 25 Shmups of All Time! - Polls Closed

Post by Zach Keene »

And now, it's time for... 5 or 6 baritone solos in the key of E? Nope, it's the 4th Annual Top 25 Shmups of All Time poll.

I've volunteered to take this over from nullstar, and it's going to work pretty much the same way it did last year. Thusly I'm just going to totally rip off nullstar's rules post from last year.

Polls Close April 1! (Results expected by May 1.)

What's New?!
(List may include console ports of games that had original arcade releases in 2004.)
Espgaluda II
Gunroar
Homura
Ibara
Mushihimesama
Nanostray
Radilgy
Raiden III
Trizeal
Twinkle Star Sprites: La Petite Princesse
Under Defeat

And a host of others I've probably forgotten about.

Also, "Tube shooters" (a la Gyruss or Tempest) will be allowed this year.


RULES:
00) If you haven't participated before, read the background section (below) before proceeding any further.
01) Vote for the 25 shmups you feel are the "top" of all time. (What constitutes top is up to you: best, favorite, most influential, most significant, mix-and-match, etc.)
02) For each shmup, allocate an integer number of points. The points you assign will help compensate for, say, games that fewer people vote for but feel much more strongly about than others they vote for.)
03) Shmups released in calendar year 2006 are not eligible for consideration.
04) Don't Vote for Games You Haven't Played! Hopefully that was self-evident...
05) Distinguish between games on compilations! (e.g. Zanac X Zanac and is not something you can vote for -- it's the name of the compilation, not a game.)
06) Specify when different games share the same title. (We're not talking about ports here -- stuff like U.N. Squadron: the SNES game and arcade game are so different we consider them separately; Gradius III SNES and arcade is another good example.) If you intend to vote for a game titled "Salamander" or "Life Force", for the love of Schirach be as specific as possible as to which format and region you're voting for.
07) No Borderliners! Stuff that's off-limits generally include: "run-and-gun" (think Contra or Mercs); arena shooters (Robotron, Smash TV, etc.); on-rails/into-the-screen shooters (Rez, Panzer Dragoon, Space Harrier, etc.). Stuff like Space Invaders and Galaga are OK.
08) Can't come up with 25? Make sure you've read the background section and still want to vote. That said: you are free to vote for fewer than 25 games, but realize that your votes will receive a smaller pie than people who vote for the full 25 games.
09) Can't limit yourself to 25? Not a problem! You can vote for 26, 27, 30, 50, 100, etc. games. But you don't get a bigger pie, so each additional game you vote for is one more game diminishing the weight of all the other games you vote for. It's up to you, but we would recommend you not dilute your vote by -- at most -- a handful of additional games.
10) USE THE VOTE FORMAT!!!!! As stated, we're trying to automate data entry, so see the Vote Format section...


Vote Format:
Votes need to be in the following format:
- one game per line
- first thing on line: the integer score to assign to the game, in brackets
- second thing on line: a space
- final thing on line before hitting enter: name of the game, in brackets

Some Examples:
[42] [Brilliant Bronzerifle]
[23] [Gradius MCMVII]
[16] [Cosmos Field]
[15] [DoReMiPachi]
[8] [1914]
[4] [Super Robo Aleste II Turbo]

BACKGROUND:
Historically, informal "top 10" shmup lists showed up on the forum with a frequency only eclipsed by the age-old questions of "Thunderforce V: PSX or Saturn?!" and "which Dreamcast shmups to buy?!" But a lot of people felt 10 was just too short a list to even begin to list the best of the best shmups...so the annual top 25 got started three years ago. It helps reduce the frequency of informal polls; it gives people a bit more choice in what to include on their list; and most importantly: it helps provides everyone an annual snapshot of what the forum's widely and deeply experienced players collectively felt was "basic background" for any serious (or aspiring) shmupper. (By the way: it's still OK to run informal top 10s...)

So what constitutes "widely and deeply experienced"? That's impossible to truly quantify, but as a general guideline: voters should be familiar with nearly all (95+%) of the games on previous years' top 25 lists. Furthermore, they should be equally familiar with nearly as many (90+%) of the shmups on previous years' honorable mention lists. And, to the extent that other games voters have listed are available, would-be voters should be familiar with 50%-65+% of those games, as well.

And what constitutes "familiar"? Basically, having played it enough to understand the gameplay mechanisms that make it unique, and/or fun and/or historically important and/or any number of other things you might take as helping define "top."

So this is just for the old and decrepit? The intent is not to make voting for a top 25 some elitist function; at the same time, the value of such a list is diminished as those lacking adequate experience participate in the voting process. Scoring mechanisms are in place to try and counteract this somewhat, but this is by no means a perfect system. Meeting the guidelines listed here will go a long way to helping ensure that the results of such votes can be trusted, and that those new to the genre and/or voting process have concrete goals that will go a long way to producing better participation and more accurate results in future years. (Even in the past couple years a number of forum members have used the results of the Top 25 poll to guide where they spend time and money as they become more familiar with the genre.)

Is this perfect? By no means -- but it's a bit of fun, helps spark some discussion, and helps provide some direction of the genres core experiences.
Last edited by Zach Keene on Sun Apr 02, 2006 6:56 am, edited 1 time in total.
User avatar
Rob
Posts: 8080
Joined: Wed Jan 26, 2005 12:58 am

Post by Rob »

[11] [Mars Matrix]
[9] [Gunbird 2]
[8] [Giga Wing 2]
[7] [Gradius V]
[6] [Dragon Blaze]
[6] [Lightening Force]
[5] [Raiden DX]
[3] [Einhander]
[3] [Giga Wing]
[3] [RayForce]
[1] [Thunder Force III]
[1] [Bio Metal]
[1] [Strikers 1945 II]
[1] [Zero Gunner 2]
[1] [Forgotten Worlds]
[1] [Shikigami II]
[1] [DoDonPachi DOJ]
[1] [Giga Wing Generations]
[1] [Macross: Scrambled Valkyrie]
[1] [Air Zonk]
[1] [Gradius Gaiden]
[1] [Parodius Da!]
[1] [Raiden]
[1] [Millipede]
[1] [Divine Sealing]
Last edited by Rob on Wed Feb 15, 2006 6:58 am, edited 1 time in total.
User avatar
zinger
Posts: 1387
Joined: Sun Jan 30, 2005 10:58 pm
Location: Sweden
Contact:

Post by zinger »

Rob wrote:[1] [Divine Sealing]
:lol:

[10] [Battle Garegga]
[10] [Border Down]
[08] [Rayforce]
[08] [Under Defeat]
[08] [Darius Gaiden]
[08] [Blazing Star]
[06] [Soukyugurentai]
[06] [Progear no Arashi]
[06] [Cotton 2]
[05] [Armed Police Batrider]
Last edited by zinger on Tue Mar 28, 2006 3:10 pm, edited 7 times in total.
User avatar
Blade
Posts: 1261
Joined: Wed Feb 09, 2005 5:24 pm
Location: Wisconsin...burr...

Post by Blade »

[100] [Radiant Silvergun]
[100] [Ikaruga]
[90] [Einhander]
[80] [Dodonpachi]
[80] [Dangun Feveron]
[70] [Guwange]
[70] [Vasara 2]
[70] [Zed Blade]
[70] [Arrowflash]
[70] [Gigawing]
[70] [Metal Black]
[60] [Cyvern]
[60] [Thunderforce 4]
[60] [Raiden III]
[60] [Shikigami no Shiro 2]
[60] [Gradius V]
[50] [Mazinger Z]
[50] [Aleste]
[50] [Pulstar]
[50] [Guardian Legend (aka Guardic Gaiden)]
[50] [Viper Phase I]
[40] [Battle Garegga]
[40] [Chaos Field]
[30] [R-Type Final]
[20] [Zero Wing (Arcade Ver.)]
Last edited by Blade on Sun Feb 19, 2006 12:45 am, edited 1 time in total.
The world would be a better place if there were less shooters and more dot-eaters.

Jesus' BE ATTITUDE FOR GAINS:
1. Pure, Mournful, Humble Heart
2. Merciful Peacemaker
3. Suffer for Righteous Desire
User avatar
IlMrm
Posts: 861
Joined: Wed Jan 26, 2005 6:52 am
Location: San Francisco, CA USA

Post by IlMrm »

[10] [Gunbird 2]
[10] [Mushihimesama]
[9] [Giga Wing 2]
[9] [Strikers 1999]
[9] [ Raiden Fighters Jet]
[9] [Raiden Fighters 2]
[8] [Strikers 1945 2]
[8] [ESPGaluda]
[8] [DoDonPachi]
[8] [Ikaruga]
[7] [Radiant Silvergun]
[7] [Mars Matrix]
[7] [Giga Wing]
[7] [Ketsui]
[6] [Zero Gunner 2]
[6] [Dragon Blaze]
[6] [DDP DOJ]
[5] [Shikigami No Shiro 2]
[5] [Strikers 1945 Plus]
[1] [Dragon Spirit]
[1] [Sky Shark]
[1] [Raiden II]
[1] [Abadox]
[1] [R-Type]
[1] [Gradius]
[1] [UN Squadron (SNES)]
User avatar
Thunder Force
Posts: 1773
Joined: Wed Jan 26, 2005 11:21 am
Location: research and development facility for Vasteel Technology.

Post by Thunder Force »

[100] [Thunderforce V]
[100] [Galaga]
[100] [Psyvariar Revision]
[80] [Soukyugurentai]
[50] [Dangun Feveron]
[50] [Mushihimesama]
[50] [Thunderforce III]
[50] [Raiden DX]
[50] [Twin Cobra]
[50] [Armed Police Batrider]
[50] [Trizeal]
[50] [Battle Bakraid]
[50] [Shikigami No Shiro II]
[50] [Gradius V]
[20] [Ikaruga]
[20] [Gaiares]
[20] [19XX: War Against Destiny]
[20] [Layer Section]
[20] [Ray Crisis]
[20] [Donpachi]
[20] [Tempest 2000]
[20] [Border Down]
[10] [Strikers 1945 II]
[10] [Noiz2sa]
[10] [Axelay]
Last edited by Thunder Force on Thu Feb 16, 2006 4:52 am, edited 2 times in total.
"Thunder Force VI does not suck, shut your fucking mouth." ~ Shane Bettenhausen
User avatar
theevilfunkster
Posts: 950
Joined: Tue Feb 01, 2005 3:49 pm
Location: Glossop, UK

Post by theevilfunkster »

[10] [Mushihimesama]
[10] [DoDonPachi]
[10] [Gradius V]
[9] [Ikaruga]
[9] [Border Down]
[9] [Thunder Force IV]
[8] [Gradius Gaiden]
[8] [Radiant Silvergun]
[8] [Life Force (NES PAL)]
[7] [Mars Matrix]
[7] [Gokujyou Parodius]
[7] [Layer Section]
[6] [Giga Wing]
[6] [Soukyugerentai]
[6] [Strikers 1945 II]
[5] [Blazing Star]
[5] [Pulstar]
[5] [Salamander 2]
[1] [Gunbird 2]
[1] [Jikkyo Oshaberi Parodius]
[1] [Trizeal]
[1] [Donpachi]
[1] [Zero Gunner 2]
[1] [Psyvariar 2]
[1] [Thunder Force V]
Image
User avatar
PlasmaBlooD
Posts: 564
Joined: Thu Jan 27, 2005 2:57 pm
Location: Germany
Contact:

Post by PlasmaBlooD »

[10] [Espgaluda]
[10] [Musha Aleste]
[10] [Gradius II]
[10] [Gate of Thunder]
[9] [Mushihime Sama]
[9] [Gradius Gaiden]
[9] [Super Aleste]
[9] [Shikigami no Shiro II]
[9] [Winds of Thunder]
[8] [Gunbird]
[8] [Donpachi]
[8] [Parodius Da]
[8] [Zanac Neo]
[8] [Gunhed]
[8] [Thunderforce IV]
[7] [Armed Police Batrider]
[7] [Dogyuun]
[7] [Strikers 1945 II]
[6] [Thunderforce III]
[6] [Elementalmaster]
[6] [Eliminate Down]
[5] [Apidya]
[5] [Wings of Death]
[5] [Hellfire]
[5] [Spriggan]
Image
User avatar
Turrican
Posts: 4735
Joined: Wed Jan 26, 2005 5:28 am
Location: Landorin
Contact:

Post by Turrican »

[10] [Gradius II ~Gofer no Yabou~ (AC)]
[10] [Xevious Arrangement]
[10] [R-Type Delta]
[10] [Raiden DX]
[10] [Tempest X₃]
[10] [Super Aleste]
[10] [Lifeforce Salamander (NES)]
[10] [Pop'n Twinbee]
[10] [Gokujou Parodius (AC)]
[10] [Thunderforce III]
[8] [Power Strike II (SMS)]
[8] [Dodonpachi]
[8] [Soukyugurentai]
[8] [Gradius Gaiden]
[8] [Musha Aleste]
[8] [Thunderforce V]
[8] [Axelay]
[8] [Gradius V]
[8] [Apidya]
[6] [Super Fantasy Zone]
[6] [Zanac Neo]
[6] [Salamander 2]
[6] [Radiant Silvergun]
[6] [Dropzone]
[6] [Biohazard Battle]
Last edited by Turrican on Thu Feb 16, 2006 6:55 pm, edited 1 time in total.
Image
X - P - B
User avatar
chtimi-CLA
Posts: 718
Joined: Wed Jan 26, 2005 10:06 am
Location: France

Post by chtimi-CLA »

[100] [Guwange]
[100] [Dangun Feveron]
[100] [Ketsui]
[100] [DoDonPachi DOJ]
[100] [Twin Cobra]
[70] [R-Type]
[70] [Thunderforce 3]
[70] [Raiden]
[70] [Raiden Fighters Jet]
[40] [Raiden Fighters 2]
[40] [Raiden DX]
[40] [Progear]
[40] [Donpachi]
[40] [Batsugun]
[40] [Hellfire] - MD JAP
[40] [Gigawing 2]
[40] [Gigawing]
[40] [Winds of thunder]
[40] [Nexzr]
[40] [Radiant Silvergun]
[40] [Ikaruga]
[40] [Galaga]
[40] [Shikigami no Shiro II]
[40] [Armed Police Batrider]
[40] [Dragon breed]
Last edited by chtimi-CLA on Tue Feb 21, 2006 11:38 am, edited 2 times in total.
User avatar
nZero
Posts: 2608
Joined: Wed Jan 26, 2005 1:20 am
Location: DC Area
Contact:

Post by nZero »

Another year, another list... I think this gets harder every year :lol:

[500] [Raiden DX]

[50] [Axelay]
[50] [Raiden]
[50] [Soldier Blade]
[50] [Thunder Force AC]

[15] [Border Down]
[15] [DoDonPachi]
[15] [ESPRa.De.]
[15] [ESPGaluda]
[15] [Giga Wing 2]
[15] [Gleylancer]
[15] [Ikaruga]
[15] [Psyvariar 2]
[15] [Raiden III]
[15] [Raiden Fighters]
[15] [RayCrisis]
[15] [Sonic Wings Special]
[15] [Soukyugurentai]
[15] [Strikers 1945 II]
[15] [Thunder Force V]
[15] [Trizeal]
[15] [Twin Cobra]
[15] [UN Squadron (Arcade)]
[15] [Viper Phase 1]
[15] [Zero Gunner 2]

These lists always seem a little alphabetically biased. I think I may have put less effort into actually ranking them this year, oh well.
Image
User avatar
bVork
Posts: 211
Joined: Wed Jun 22, 2005 7:44 am
Location: the left coast of canada

Post by bVork »

[15] [Tempest]
[10] [Summer Carnival '92: Recca]
[9] [Space Invaders]

[6] [Ikaruga]
[6] [Gradius 2]
[5] [Radiant Silvergun]
[5] [Shikigami No Shiro 2]
[5] [Apidya]
[4] [Gradius Gaiden]
[3] [Dodonpachi]

[1] [Galactic Attack]
[1] [Giga Wing]
[1] [Imperishable Night]
[1] [Twin Cobra]
[1] [Katakis (C64)]
[1] [Battle Garegga]
[1] [R-Type]
[1] [Border Down]
[1] [Salamander (NES)]
[1] [ESPgaluda]
[1] [Thunder Force III]
[1] [Robo Aleste]
[1] [G-Darius]
[1] [Zanac]
[1] [Return of the Invaders]
Last edited by bVork on Mon Feb 27, 2006 7:33 pm, edited 4 times in total.
User avatar
crithit5000
Posts: 925
Joined: Thu Jan 27, 2005 3:17 am
Location: Youngstown OH, USA
Contact:

Post by crithit5000 »

[30] [Giga Wing]

[20] [Ikaruga]
[20] [Battle Garegga]
[20] [DoDonPachi]
[20] [Gunbird 2]
[20] [Strikers 1945 II]
[20] [Shikigami No Shiro II]
[20] [Gradius III - Arcade]
[20] [DonPachi]
[20] [Battle Bakraid]
[20] [Armed Police Batrider]
[20] [ESP Ra. De.]
[20] [Giga Wing 2]

[10] [Radiant Silvergun]
[10] [Darius Gaiden]
[10] [Strikers 1999]
[10] [Sengoku Ace]
[10] [Strikers 1945]
[10] [Vasara]
[10] [R-Type Leo]
[10] [1942]

[5] [Trizeal]
[5] [19XX: The War Against Destiny]
[5] [Gradius - Arcade]
[5] [Gradius V]
Image
now tighter than your sister
User avatar
Neon
Posts: 3529
Joined: Tue Jan 25, 2005 10:31 pm

Post by Neon »

[5] [Battle Garegga]
[5] [Dangun Feveron]
[5] [Raiden DX]
[5] [G Darius]
[5] [Mars Matrix]
User avatar
DC906270
Posts: 993
Joined: Wed Apr 27, 2005 7:34 pm
Location: THE UK!!!

Post by DC906270 »

[100] [Dodonpachi Dai-ou-jou- PS2]
[100] [Battle Garegga - SATURN]
[080] [R-Type - Arcade/PS1 JAP]
[080] [UN Squadron - SNES JAP]
[080] [Hellfire - MD JAP]
[080] [Darius - Arcade Jap]
[080] [Darius 2 - Arcade Jap]
[080] [Gigawing 2 - DC Jap]
[080] [Espgaluda - PS2]
[070] [Darius Gaiden - SATURN JAP]
[070] [Dragon Spirit - PC Engine]
[050] [Mushihimesama - ARCADE/PS2]
[050] [Tatsujin - MD]
[040] [Progear - ARCADE US]
[040] [Raiden DX - PS1]
[040] [Batsugun SATURN]
[035] [Kyukyoku Tiger II - SATURN]
[030] [Dragon Breed - ARCADE JAP]
[030] [Strikers 1945 - SATURN JAP]
[020] [Aeroblasters - MD]
Last edited by DC906270 on Wed Feb 15, 2006 7:57 pm, edited 6 times in total.
User avatar
BulletMagnet
Posts: 14416
Joined: Wed Jan 26, 2005 4:05 am
Location: Wherever.
Contact:

Post by BulletMagnet »

Okay, I think it's about done for this time around...

[10] [DoDonPachi]

[9] [Radiant Silvergun]

[8] [Cotton Boomerang]
[8] [ESPGaluda]

[7] [DoDonPachi Dai-Ou-Jou]
[7] [Guwange]
[7] [Imperishable Night]
[7] [Perfect Cherry Blossom]

[6] [Battle Bakraid]
[6] [ESP Ra.de]
[6] [Super Aleste/Space Megaforce]

[5] [Batsugun (Special Ver.)]
[5] [Harmful Park]

[4] [Shikigami no Shiro 2]
[4] [Twinkle Star Sprites]
[4] [Vasara 2]

[3] [Bike Banditz]
[3] [Vasara]

[2] [19XX: The War Against Destiny]
[2] [Blazing Star]

[1] [Battle Garegga]
[1] [Gradius V]
[1] [Ikaruga]
[1] [Mars Matrix]
[1] [Mushihime-Sama]
Last edited by BulletMagnet on Sat Apr 01, 2006 3:51 am, edited 5 times in total.
User avatar
jp
Posts: 3243
Joined: Wed Jan 26, 2005 12:11 am
Location: Huntsville, AL
Contact:

Post by jp »

[20] [Radiant Silvergun]

[10] [Border Down]

[8] [Mars Matrix]
[8] [Hyper Duel]


[7] [Soukyuugurentai]
[7] [Batsugun]
[7] [Battle Garegga]

[6] [Game Tengoku]
[6] [Blast Wind]
[6] [Thunder Force III]

[5] [Thunder Force IV]
[5] [Salamander II]
[5] [Raystorm]

[4] [Nexzr]
[4] [Sexy Parodius]
[4] [Metal Black]

[3] [Gokujyo Parodius]
[3] [Truxton]
[3] [Gradius II Gofer]

[2] [Cotton 2]
[2] [Lords of Thunder]
[2] [Trizeal]

[1] [Ikaruga]
[1] [Hellfire]
[1] [Twinkle Star Sprites]


And there's my 25. Probably forgot something... probably didn't rank them exactly as I normally would... but its close enough.
Last edited by jp on Thu Feb 16, 2006 8:32 pm, edited 2 times in total.
RABBLE RABBLE RABBLE!!!!!!
User avatar
Lone Deranger
Posts: 52
Joined: Sun Dec 11, 2005 11:08 am
Location: Tokyo

Post by Lone Deranger »

[10] [Super Aleste]
[9] [Dangun Feveron]
[9] [Armalyte (C64)]
[9] [Battle Squadron]
[8] [Final Soldier]
[8] [R-Type]
[7] [Ikaruga]
[7] [Battle Garegga]
[6] [Soukyugurentai]
[6] [DoDonPachi]
[6] [Override]
[6] [Blazing Star]
[6] [Strikers 1945]
[5] [GunHed]
[5] [Thunder Force III]
[5] [Blood Money]
[5] [Soldier Blade]
[5] [Pop 'n Twinbee]
[4] [Axelay]
[4] [Border Down]
[4] [Silk Worm]
[3] [Hybris]
[3] [Super Star Soldier]
[2] [IO]
[1] [Galaga '88]

Somewhat unconventional when comparing to most lists here. :)
Trust in Trance
User avatar
Dale
Posts: 1390
Joined: Thu Jan 19, 2006 10:31 pm

Post by Dale »

[25] [Vulgus]
[24] [Shikigami no Shiro2]
[23] [Gigawing]
[22] [Dodonpachi]
[22] [Galaga]
[21] [MUSHA]
[20] [Gunbird2]
[19] [Zero Wing]
[19] [Gaiares]
[18] [Marz Matrix]
[18] [Gunsmoke]
[16] [Raiden2]
[15] [Parsec 47]
[14] [Thunder Force2]
[13] [Exed Eyes]
[12] [Phoenix]
[12] [Fireshark]
[12] [Silpheed2]
[10] [Tokio]
[10] [Defender2]
[10] [Grid Seeker]
[10] [Satan,s Hollow]
[8] [Zanac]
[6] [Galaga88]
[4] [Sinastar]


I think I might have my list backwards I want Vulgus as number1 and Ghost pilots as my last pick, tell me if I,m doing this wrong.
Last edited by Dale on Thu Mar 30, 2006 11:11 pm, edited 6 times in total.
User avatar
Ganelon
Posts: 4413
Joined: Tue Feb 01, 2005 1:43 am

Post by Ganelon »

[9] [Gaiares]
[9] [Hyper Duel]
[1] [Batsugun Special Ver.]
[1] [Blast Wind]
[1] [Batrider]
[1] [Last Resort]
[1] [Android Assault]
[1] [Border Down]
[1] [Aldynes]
[1] [Darius Gaiden]
[1] [dodonpachi DAI-OU-JOU]
[1] [Image Fight]
[1] [Image Fight II]
[1] [Robo Aleste]
[1] [Psyvariar 2]
[1] [Radiant Silvergun]
[1] [Thunder Force III]
[1] [Thunder Force IV]
[1] [Thunder Force V]
[1] [Gate of Thunder]
[1] [Lords of Thunder]
[1] [Sol Feace]
[1] [G.Darius]
[1] [Macross Scrambled Valkyrie]
[1] [Nexzr]
User avatar
professor ganson
Posts: 5193
Joined: Mon Feb 21, 2005 3:59 am
Location: OHIO

Post by professor ganson »

[5] [Dragon Blaze]
[4] [Raiden DX]
[4] [Gunbird 2]
[4] [Mars Matrix]
[4] [Battle Garegga]
[4] [Shikigami no Shiro II]
[4] [Zanac Neo]
[4] [Twin Cobra]
[4] [Gradius V]
[4] [Gigawing]
[3] [Harmful Park]
[3] [Gradius Gaiden]
[3] [Strikers 1945]
[3] [Gigawing 2]
[3] [R-Type]
[2] [Radiant Silvergun]
[2] [Soukyugurentai]
[2] [Strikers 1945 II]
[2] [Zanac]
[1] [Batsugun]
[1] [Raiden II]
[1] [Salamander 2]
[1] [Pulstar]
[1] [Viewpoint]
[1] [R-Type Delta]
Last edited by professor ganson on Sat Apr 01, 2006 2:29 am, edited 2 times in total.
User avatar
Fighter17
Banned User
Posts: 2291
Joined: Sun Feb 06, 2005 2:48 am
Location: Inside a computer
Contact:

Post by Fighter17 »

[1] [UN Squadron (Arcade)]
[2] [Carrier Air Wing (US Navy)]
[3] [DoDonPachi]
[4] [Giga Wing]
[5] [Gradius V]
[6] [Thunder Force III]
[7] [Axelay]
[8] [Change Air Blade]
[9] [Zanac Neo]
[10] [R-Type III]
[11] [Blazing Lasers (Gunhed)]
[12] [Blazing Star]
[13] [Sexy Parodius]
[14] [19XX: The War Against Destiny]
[15] [Ikruaga]
[16] [Aero Fighters II]
[17] [Fire Shark]
[18] [Batsugun]
[19] [Guwange]
[20] [M.U.S.H.A]
[21] [Salamander II]
[22] [Soukyugurentai]
[23] [Solder Blade]
[24] [Lords of Thunder]
[25] [Battle Garegga]

I hope I did this list correctly. :) Batle Garegga is always been my favorite shmup because it was just damn perfect.

25 is my favorite shmup FYI.
Last edited by Fighter17 on Tue Feb 21, 2006 3:08 am, edited 3 times in total.
User avatar
Gakidou
Posts: 88
Joined: Mon Sep 05, 2005 6:44 pm
Location: Sweden

Post by Gakidou »

[10] [Dodonpachi]
[9] [Battle Garegga]
[8] [Ikaruga]
[7] [Espgaluda]
[6] [U.N. Squadron (SNES)]
[5] [Progear no Arashi]
[4] [Dodonpachi DOJ]
[3] [R-Type Delta]
[2] [Mushihimesama]
[1] [Life Force (NES)]
User avatar
battlegorge
Posts: 67
Joined: Thu Feb 16, 2006 12:39 pm

Post by battlegorge »

[10] [Gradius Gaiden]
[10] [Strikers 1945 Plus]
[10] [Cho Ren Sha 68k]
[9] [Gradius]
[9] [Raiden DX]
[9] [Cyvern]
[9] [Donpachi]
[9] [R-Type]
[8] [Gradius 2]
[8] [Harmful Park]
[8] [Raystorm]
[8] [Raiden]
[8] [Parodius Da!]
[8] [Gunbird]
[7] [R-Type Delta]
[7] [Super Star Soldier]
[7] [Override]
[7] [Tumiki Fighters]
[7] [Revenge of the Robot Cats from Mars]
[7] [Thundercross]
[7] [Vasara]
[7] [Viper Phase 1]
[7] [Image Fight]
[7] [Chariot]
[7] [Solar Striker]
Last edited by battlegorge on Thu Feb 16, 2006 3:44 pm, edited 3 times in total.
User avatar
agony
Posts: 127
Joined: Thu Jul 21, 2005 8:25 am
Location: Germany
Contact:

Post by agony »

[30] [ESPGaluda]
[25] [Mushihimesama]
[15] [ESP Ra. De.]
[10] [DoDonPachi]
[10] [Progear]
[5] [Raiden III]
[5] [Homura]
[1] [Gunbird]
[1] [Gunbird 2]
User avatar
raiden
Posts: 862
Joined: Tue Jan 25, 2005 11:41 pm
Location: Cologne
Contact:

Post by raiden »

[3] [Twinkle Star Sprites]
[3] [Vulgus]
[3] [Flying Shark]

[2] [Tumiki Fighters]
[2] [Giga Wing]
[2] [Blazing Star]
[2] [Guwange]
[2] [Phoenix]
[2] [ESP Galuda]
[2] [Dodonpachi]

[1] [Mars Matrix (CPS2)]
[1] [Strikers 1945 II]
[1] [Raiden DX]
[1] [Battle Garegga]
[1] [Terra Cresta]
[1] [N2O aka Nitrous Oxyde]
[1] [Twin Hawk]
[1] [Raiden Fighters Jet]
[1] [Bike Banditz]
[1] [Imperishable Night]
[1] [Dragon Blaze]
[1] [Dimahoo]
[1] [Dangun Feveron]
[1] [Star Soldier (Gamecube version)]
[1] [Slap Fight]

I´ve been waiting eagerly for this vote, but now I find it harder than ever, because the criteria get mixed up all the time. I´ve tried to incorporate innovative/unique factor, influential factor (already contradicting slightly), but of course also overall quality, subjective fun, and many times these factors didn´t only influence the points each game got, but also the choice which games to include in the vote at all. Recently, I´ve been out of the loop a little, didn´t play Ibara, Under Defeat, Homura or Radirugy. So I considered reducing my number of votes, but given the underwhelming effect most new shmups have had on me for the last few years, I don´t expect any of these titles to have an influence on my votes, therefore I kept it at 25.
User avatar
sven666
Posts: 4545
Joined: Wed Feb 02, 2005 2:04 am
Location: sweden
Contact:

Post by sven666 »

[100] [Batrider -arcade]
[090] [Ketsui - arcade]
[080] [R-Type Delta - PSX]
[070] [Battle garegga - arcade/sat]
[060] [Raiden fighters 2 - arcade]
[050] [Dodonpachi daioujou - Arcade/ps2]
[040] [Gigawing - Arcade/dc]
[030] [Progear - arcade]
[020] [G-darius - arcade/PSX]
[010] [Ikaruga - arcade/dc/gc]
[000] [Axelay - Snes]
the destruction of everything, is the beginning of something new. your whole world is on fire, and soon, you'll be too..
User avatar
russ
Posts: 177
Joined: Thu Apr 21, 2005 3:38 am
Location: Dallas area, TX

Post by russ »

[10] [Ketsui]

[9] [Souykugurentai]
[9] [Battle Garegga]
[8] [Radiant Silvergun]
[8] [Einhander]
[7] [R-Type III - The Third Lightning]
[7] [Dodonpachi]
[6] [R-Type II]
[6] [Batrider]

[5] [Giga Wing]
[5] [Gradius II]
[4] [Strikers 1999]
[4] [Raiden Fighters II]
[4] [Gradius Gaiden]
[3] [Rayforce]
[3] [Raiden II]
[3] [G-Darius]
[2] [R-Type Delta]
[2] [Dodonpachi DOJ]
[2] [Battle Bakraid]
[1] [Mars Matrix]
[1] [Psyvariar II]
[1] [Gradius III (SNES)]
[1] [Darius Gaiden]
[1] [Cyvern]

Man, that wasn't an easy list to make. :oops:
"No beer until you've finished your tequila!"
User avatar
JBC
Posts: 3846
Joined: Wed Mar 30, 2005 3:14 am

Post by JBC »

[100] [Viper - Phase 1]
[90] [Gradius IV]
[90] [R-Type Leo]
[90] [Pulstar]
[80] [Raiden Fighters]
[80] [DoDonPachi]
[80] [Mars Matrix]
[70] [Raystorm]
[70] [Strikers 1945 III]
[70] [Gradius V]
[70] [Thunder Force IV]
[70] [1944 - the Loop Master]
[60] [Strikers 1945 II]
[60] [Battle Bakraid]
[50] [Forgotten Worlds]
[50] [Battle Garegga]
[50] [DoDonPachi DOJ]
[40] [Thunderforce III]
[40] [Salamander II]
[40] [Gradius Galaxies]
[40] [Blazing Star]
[30] [Raiden Fighters II]
[30] [Strikers 1945]
[20] [Darius Gaiden]
[10] [DonPachi]
User avatar
Bydobasher
Posts: 265
Joined: Wed Jan 26, 2005 4:16 pm
Location: The Bydo Empire

Post by Bydobasher »

[1] [Aleste (MSX)]
[1] [Apidya]
[1] [Axelay]
[1] [Battle Garegga]
[1] [Cho Ren Sha 68K]
[1] [Einhander]
[1] [G Darius]
[1] [Gate of Thunder]
[1] [Gradius 2 (NES)]
[1] [Image Fight]
[1] [Last Resort]
[1] [M.U.S.H.A.]
[1] [Power Strike 2 (SMS)]
[1] [Pulstar]
[1] [R-Type]
[1] [R-Type Delta]
[1] [RayForce]
[1] [Salamander (PCE)]
[1] [Sorcer Striker]
[1] [Space Manbow]
[1] [Space Megaforce]
[1] [Thunder Force 5]
[1] [Time Pilot]
[1] [Viewpoint]
[1] [Xexex (Japan)]
Last edited by Bydobasher on Sat Apr 01, 2006 11:00 am, edited 11 times in total.
Locked