Hmm let me think. I saw it a while ago. I'd say that it's overall a lot better produced, grittier, with better acting. Unless you're a fan of totally over-the-top HK acting; in that case you may be disappointed. It hits most of the same plot points.njiska wrote:Really? I'd been largely avoiding it because I've heard relatively bland reviews. Can you give a bit more detailed review? Since you Liked it, I'd really like to get your opinion.louisg wrote:The remake of A Better Tomorrow was pretty good. No Ronin on this list?
And yeah, how has Ronin not been mentioned yet? One of De Niro's best films and the car chases are brilliant, especially the big one.
I don't know if I'd call a lot of it genuinely great acting. I think The Killer is great, as is Hard Boiled. There are a couple scenes that I think are convincing, but a lot of it is so melodramatic and crazy that there's just not a lot of subtlety left in it. Or, I guess I could say it's good acting along the lines of Face/Off (and whether that's good is open to interpretationnjiska wrote:That doesn't mean there isn't good storytelling though. My specific reference for this comment was not Red Cliff, but The Killer and A Better Tomorrow. Both have great action, but also really good stories, good characters and some genuinely great acting. The apartment confrontation between Chow Yun-Fat and Danny Lee in The Killer is a particular favourite of scene of mine.

The apartment scene in The Killer is classic. I really dig it.