Monitor without apparent scanlines
-
FinalBaton
- Posts: 4461
- Joined: Sun Mar 08, 2015 10:38 pm
- Location: Québec City
Re: Monitor without apparent scanlines
Even though it's not arcade perfect : that JVC looks amazing! at least to me
one of the prettiest crt picture I've ever seen. will definitely grab one down the road
one of the prettiest crt picture I've ever seen. will definitely grab one down the road
-FM Synth & Black Metal-
-
- Posts: 873
- Joined: Thu Sep 11, 2014 3:37 pm
Re: Monitor without apparent scanlines
Smaller is easy. There is still an abundance of 17", 14" and 8" 15khz rgb monitors and, with some exceptions, they are still cheap as they are less desirable.Brando1975 wrote:I agree with you in 100%, this monitor is not for more modern games, it is perfect for the late 80s / early 90's classics, I also agree with you that it's very small, my 21" sony wega is fantastic, but I want to have something smaller now
For example, this 1702 going for $100 plus another $100 for shipping and you get the Commodore 64 with it... I don't think that monitor has RGB though.
Or $100 for this Apple RGB cga and ega monitor delivered:
https://www.ebay.com/itm/Vintage-Apple- ... SwiYlZ-4oV
They are a dime a dozen on eBay and Craigslist....
-
- Posts: 873
- Joined: Thu Sep 11, 2014 3:37 pm
Re: Monitor without apparent scanlines
We'll have to agree to disagree on this one.MKL wrote:Not all Commodore monitors are the same. The 1702 uses an A tube (vertical phosphor stripes, slotted mask) while the 1084 uses an M tube (dot phosphor pattern, circular hole mask) like a PC monitor. The difference is pretty evident. An A tube will look like this JVC monitor.Classicgamer wrote:I don't think a commodore monitor is the way to go for an authentic arcade experience.
14" (13" viewable) is definitely an arcade size. It was used in cocktail cabinets.Classicgamer wrote:Most arcade monitors were either 19" (visible) or 25". My old favorites like double dragon, final fight and SF2 never looked or felt "arcade-like" on anything smaller than 19".
The 1702 doesn't have an rgb input does it?
I'll concede that not all Commodore monitors were the same. Some were average and some were way worse. None of them could be considered a top 10 choice for vintage arcade gaming. There is a reason why there are so many still available on eBay... I put up with one temporarily back in the day until I could afford a Sony Trinitron tv for my room.
While I'm not one of them, I can understand the group who like the Sony BVM look. I can obviously understand the people who like real arcade monitors and consumer CRT TVs with nice 19" and 25" screens. I will never understand the group that recommends tiny low end CGA monitors from the Commodore 64 era. They were not considered desirable even in the 80's.
It is true that, occasionally, smaller monitors were used with arcade games. I don't remember cocktail cabinets using screens as small as 14". There were a few novelty bar top arcades with 14" CRTs but you would never ever find one in a real arcade. You found them in pubs to use while you waited for your pint.
To each his own I guess...
Re: Monitor without apparent scanlines
Most little RGB monitors with a good CRT look like this. I like it too.Brando1975 wrote:Can someone recommend me a monitor that does not have apparent scanlines like this JVC?
In Australia a 14" monitor was a common size for cocktail cabinets. Some upright cabinets had them too. I bought a Lowboy (kid size, very common) cabinet several years ago that had a 14" vertical monitor fitted.Classicgamer wrote:We'll have to agree to disagree on this one.MKL wrote:14" (13" viewable) is definitely an arcade size. It was used in cocktail cabinets.Classicgamer wrote:Most arcade monitors were either 19" (visible) or 25". My old favorites like double dragon, final fight and SF2 never looked or felt "arcade-like" on anything smaller than 19".
Re: Monitor without apparent scanlines
The 1702 doesn't have RGB but has an arcade type tube. The 1084 has RGB but doesn't have an arcade type tube. If you're going for an authentic arcade experience neither is accurate. The 1084 isn't less arcade authentic than the Ikegami you praised in another thread though.Classicgamer wrote: We'll have to agree to disagree on this one.
The 1702 doesn't have an rgb input does it?
If a "real arcade" is an arcade of the 90s you would be right but in the 80s they were quite popular. Many classic games had a cocktail version: Pac Man, Donkey Kong, Q-bert, Centipede, etc. and they had 13" monitors like Electrohome G07, Sanyo EZ, Wells Gardner 4700, etc. And I've read that you like the Hantarex Polo, well there is a 14" version that is pretty common at least in Europe. So I confirm what I said above, 14" (or 13" vieawable) is an arcade size. Where we seem to agree is that it's too small, I also don't want anything in that size for that reason.Classicgamer wrote: It is true that, occasionally, smaller monitors were used with arcade games. I don't remember cocktail cabinets using screens as small as 14". There were a few novelty bar top arcades with 14" CRTs but you would never ever find one in a real arcade.
-
- Posts: 873
- Joined: Thu Sep 11, 2014 3:37 pm
Re: Monitor without apparent scanlines
Australia? Like that's even a real place... Next you'll be telling us about the monitors in Narnia?
14" arcade monitors were most definately not common in Europe (where I lived in the 80's and 90's).
Cocktail cabinets were only common in hotels and bars (but not that common thankfully). More importantly, if an arcade mainly had 14" monitors in their cabs, I would have gone to a different arcade.
There is no effective difference between a CGA arcade tube and an SD consumer crt tv tube. In fact, some are even interchangeable. In Europe, where most mid to high end TVs had RGB scart sockets, we were able to play jamma PCBs at home (with a supergun) without any scan or color space converters.
A key feature and a necessity for an Arcade monitor is an RGB input though. That is also a necessity for any retro games monitor that deserves a recommendation for 240p mame. If you have to use svideo or composite then almost any decent consumer CRT tv is a better option.
If the point is that the type of mask is what makes it an "arcade type tube" or not, I think you are overestimating the importance of the mask for this topic. Sony Trinitrons use the same style of mask but, the image looks completely different on an RGB consumer Trinitron tv to a PVM or a Trinitron pc monitor. It's the pitch size, tvl capability, bloom and contrast that matters.
The rgb image on a consumer Trinitron actually looks very arcade-like. You can see a small difference up close but it's still closer than any pro grade rgb monitor. Gaps between scanlines are not visible at normal playing distances etc.
Similarly, the shadow mask on my broadcast monitor looks nothing like the shadow mask on my arcade monitors.
Anyway, if we agree that the 1702 and 1084 are both too small and you know that the 1702 doesn't have RGB and that the 1084 doesn't look very "arcade-like", why put so much effort into defending them? It doesn't sound like you rate them as a top retro gaming monitor choice either....
Let's all agree that we in the retro gaming community will no longer mention Commodore monitors when people ask for recommendations unless they are specifically looking for an authentic Commodore 64 experience.
14" arcade monitors were most definately not common in Europe (where I lived in the 80's and 90's).
Cocktail cabinets were only common in hotels and bars (but not that common thankfully). More importantly, if an arcade mainly had 14" monitors in their cabs, I would have gone to a different arcade.
There is no effective difference between a CGA arcade tube and an SD consumer crt tv tube. In fact, some are even interchangeable. In Europe, where most mid to high end TVs had RGB scart sockets, we were able to play jamma PCBs at home (with a supergun) without any scan or color space converters.
A key feature and a necessity for an Arcade monitor is an RGB input though. That is also a necessity for any retro games monitor that deserves a recommendation for 240p mame. If you have to use svideo or composite then almost any decent consumer CRT tv is a better option.
If the point is that the type of mask is what makes it an "arcade type tube" or not, I think you are overestimating the importance of the mask for this topic. Sony Trinitrons use the same style of mask but, the image looks completely different on an RGB consumer Trinitron tv to a PVM or a Trinitron pc monitor. It's the pitch size, tvl capability, bloom and contrast that matters.
The rgb image on a consumer Trinitron actually looks very arcade-like. You can see a small difference up close but it's still closer than any pro grade rgb monitor. Gaps between scanlines are not visible at normal playing distances etc.
Similarly, the shadow mask on my broadcast monitor looks nothing like the shadow mask on my arcade monitors.
Anyway, if we agree that the 1702 and 1084 are both too small and you know that the 1702 doesn't have RGB and that the 1084 doesn't look very "arcade-like", why put so much effort into defending them? It doesn't sound like you rate them as a top retro gaming monitor choice either....
Let's all agree that we in the retro gaming community will no longer mention Commodore monitors when people ask for recommendations unless they are specifically looking for an authentic Commodore 64 experience.
-
- Posts: 37
- Joined: Mon Aug 17, 2015 3:34 am
Re: Monitor without apparent scanlines
Yes, my Sony Wega looks like an a real arcade monitor (240p component), and the JVC monitor looks amazing too.
will low-end panasonic looks the same? Apparently monitors that are more expensive has a tendency to show more scanlines and less
shadow mask.
will low-end panasonic looks the same? Apparently monitors that are more expensive has a tendency to show more scanlines and less
shadow mask.
-
- Posts: 9
- Joined: Mon May 09, 2016 2:33 am
- Location: Toronto
Re: Monitor without apparent scanlines
For subtle scanlines and a good-size screen, try a Sony PVM-2530
Re: Monitor without apparent scanlines
I typically try to take video of various arcade machines I run across at various conventions and what not for this express purpose of fellow CRT aficionados (hope I can get a better phone or root my current phone so I can gain shutter speed access), and topics like this one. There were a bit more people actually playing on them this time around, so I couldn't get a good view of most of the machines this time around...
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_VJkoW6PuKs
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_VJkoW6PuKs
-
- Posts: 2188
- Joined: Mon Aug 14, 2017 8:34 pm
Re: Monitor without apparent scanlines
Someone mentioned this already, but what you're looking for may be much simpler than you think. Just find any CRT in a size that allows you to sit away far enough from it while being comfortable to look at. Even on the hated Sony BVM scanlines are not noticeable if seen from enough distance (and additionally you get all the benefits of a BVM such as sharp image, incredible colors and contrast, etc.).
This of course implies that recreating the arcade experience does not involve sitting with your face a short distance from the screen.
This of course implies that recreating the arcade experience does not involve sitting with your face a short distance from the screen.
-
FinalBaton
- Posts: 4461
- Joined: Sun Mar 08, 2015 10:38 pm
- Location: Québec City
Re: Monitor without apparent scanlines
Just wanted to share a pic from a member here of his consumer Trinitron set. I really like it, it has a nice amount of blooming, not a high TVL count. Beautiful grain to this picture.
-FM Synth & Black Metal-
-
- Posts: 37
- Joined: Mon Aug 17, 2015 3:34 am
Re: Monitor without apparent scanlines
The cheaper, the better..
-
- Posts: 2188
- Joined: Mon Aug 14, 2017 8:34 pm
Re: Monitor without apparent scanlines
That pic is good info for those of us who like to play with our nose two inches away from the screen
-
- Posts: 208
- Joined: Thu Sep 27, 2018 1:04 am
Re: Monitor without apparent scanlines
To that end:Brando1975 wrote:The cheaper, the better..
-
- Posts: 386
- Joined: Sun Jul 04, 2010 11:14 pm
Re: Monitor without apparent scanlines
Here's something I was screwing around with awhile back when I was experimenting to replicate older monitors. If you dial back the actual scanline strength a bit, you can actually mirror the old monitor effects on the ossc now.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KwHgqxQepOM
Shame aside from my setup you need an actual firmware update to do this.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KwHgqxQepOM
Shame aside from my setup you need an actual firmware update to do this.
"Don't HD my SD!!"
-
- Posts: 2188
- Joined: Mon Aug 14, 2017 8:34 pm
Re: Monitor without apparent scanlines
I've been seeing this pic going around and the thing that bothers me is that the PVM image is clearly using RGB. Try one of PVM usingng composite and, especially when seen from a normal distance, it won't be any different from "What retro games actually looked like" (just a bit sharper and with better colors of course).energizerfellow wrote:To that end:Brando1975 wrote:The cheaper, the better..
headlesshobbs wrote:Here's something I was screwing around with awhile back when I was experimenting to replicate older monitors. If you dial back the actual scanline strength a bit, you can actually mirror the old monitor effects on the ossc now.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KwHgqxQepOM
Shame aside from my setup you need an actual firmware update to do this.
Now this looks really interesting! I want to see how this will look on a 4K OLED.
-
- Posts: 386
- Joined: Sun Jul 04, 2010 11:14 pm
Re: Monitor without apparent scanlines
Just for fun I thought I'd compare my image to the one posted.
https://ibb.co/wgpNJ1P
I sure hope Bob doesn't get the impression I'm competing with him or anything.
https://ibb.co/wgpNJ1P
I sure hope Bob doesn't get the impression I'm competing with him or anything.
"Don't HD my SD!!"
Re: Monitor without apparent scanlines
This would be the definitive scanline/crt effect for the OSSC.headlesshobbs wrote:Here's something I was screwing around with awhile back when I was experimenting to replicate older monitors. If you dial back the actual scanline strength a bit, you can actually mirror the old monitor effects on the ossc now.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KwHgqxQepOM
Shame aside from my setup you need an actual firmware update to do this.
Strikers1945guy wrote:"Do we....eat chicken balls?!"
Re: Monitor without apparent scanlines
The picture of Link is mine and taken out of context. All are blurry and you can't see the individual lines on the BVM. I have pictures somewhere of the World Heroes title screen across all those CRT's, plus an actual arcade monitor that shows the difference. All are EXCELLENT and the 1000-line BVM looks stunning. Still, they're all different, so people should just use what they're eyes prefer. The only "wrong" answer is telling people something is "bad" - All preference, all excellent choices.
-
- Posts: 873
- Joined: Thu Sep 11, 2014 3:37 pm
Re: Monitor without apparent scanlines
What retro games actually looked like depends heavily on where you lived, how good your TV was and how you connected it.
I am sure we all owned lots of TVs and every one looked a little different. The hyper visible gaps between scanlines on the BVM and PVM has far more to do with the pitch and limited bloom than whether the user chose SVideo or RGB though. A high end broadcast monitor has thick scanlines even with SVideo and composite.
When I was a kid, my Master System, SNES, Megadrive, Neo Geo and PS1 were all connected to consumer TV's through RGB and it never looked like a pro broadcast monitor. Using RGB made 16 bit consoles look a little more jagged because of improved color seperation but I don't remember being bothered by excessive scanlines.
Even on consumer Trinitrons, they were never visible at normal playing distances but, as with any other tv or monitor, scanlines were there if you looked close enough. For example:
Up close on a mid 90's consumer Trinitron through SVideo:
Scanlines are clearly visible but... at normal playing distance, you would never see them:
I am sure we all owned lots of TVs and every one looked a little different. The hyper visible gaps between scanlines on the BVM and PVM has far more to do with the pitch and limited bloom than whether the user chose SVideo or RGB though. A high end broadcast monitor has thick scanlines even with SVideo and composite.
When I was a kid, my Master System, SNES, Megadrive, Neo Geo and PS1 were all connected to consumer TV's through RGB and it never looked like a pro broadcast monitor. Using RGB made 16 bit consoles look a little more jagged because of improved color seperation but I don't remember being bothered by excessive scanlines.
Even on consumer Trinitrons, they were never visible at normal playing distances but, as with any other tv or monitor, scanlines were there if you looked close enough. For example:
Up close on a mid 90's consumer Trinitron through SVideo:
Scanlines are clearly visible but... at normal playing distance, you would never see them:
-
- Posts: 873
- Joined: Thu Sep 11, 2014 3:37 pm
Re: Monitor without apparent scanlines
I think this pic is a fairer representation of what I have experienced from high end broadcast monitors like the BVM 20 and the Ikegami TM20-90r:
While that isn't under a microscope like the other images shown, it is still far closer than a normal person would ever sit.
If you sit close but still within the range of where normal people would sit, the image starts to look a lot more pleasing:
And if you sit where I like, about 3 foot from the screen which is reasonable for a 20", and play around with the settings (as I also dislike thick black lines across my screen). you end up with a very nice image indeed:
It's the contrast and dynamic range where high end displays really excel. It makes more of a difference than resolution sometimes and CRT tech was particularly strong in this respect. Only bettered recently by OLED.
Pics never do them justice but they can give an idea of what you can achieve with contrast and brightness adjustments in relation to scanlines prominance:
While that isn't under a microscope like the other images shown, it is still far closer than a normal person would ever sit.
If you sit close but still within the range of where normal people would sit, the image starts to look a lot more pleasing:
And if you sit where I like, about 3 foot from the screen which is reasonable for a 20", and play around with the settings (as I also dislike thick black lines across my screen). you end up with a very nice image indeed:
It's the contrast and dynamic range where high end displays really excel. It makes more of a difference than resolution sometimes and CRT tech was particularly strong in this respect. Only bettered recently by OLED.
Pics never do them justice but they can give an idea of what you can achieve with contrast and brightness adjustments in relation to scanlines prominance:
-
- Posts: 37
- Joined: Mon Aug 17, 2015 3:34 am
Re: Monitor without apparent scanlines
We never saw pronounced scanlines in the arcades of the 80's (that is something objective), you could see those thick lines of bvm at 1 km of distance.
-
- Posts: 386
- Joined: Sun Jul 04, 2010 11:14 pm
Re: Monitor without apparent scanlines
A lot of monitors used back in the 80's didn't do a great job of separating the lines, but instead we had all manner of vertical lines produced by the various types of raster arrays that was common in each monitor. Sprites were fuzzy and all this lead to them having a specific character to look like sprites instead of lego blocks trying to impersonate an image.
It's funny when I look at lcd's trying to upscale and we complain about the games looking way worse, but honestly if we could throw in those raster lines, the graphics wouldn't look hardly that much different.
It's funny when I look at lcd's trying to upscale and we complain about the games looking way worse, but honestly if we could throw in those raster lines, the graphics wouldn't look hardly that much different.
Last edited by headlesshobbs on Wed Dec 05, 2018 3:54 am, edited 1 time in total.
"Don't HD my SD!!"
-
- Posts: 2188
- Joined: Mon Aug 14, 2017 8:34 pm
Re: Monitor without apparent scanlines
Even on that arcade monitor scanlines look rather noticeable to me.
In any case, rather than how stuff looked like to us in the 80s or 90s, if time and budget allows I don't see why not go for the best possible picture quality attainable. The nostalgia does not reside on picture quality anyway, but on the gaming experience and graphical and musical styles characteristic of games of those decades.
In any case, rather than how stuff looked like to us in the 80s or 90s, if time and budget allows I don't see why not go for the best possible picture quality attainable. The nostalgia does not reside on picture quality anyway, but on the gaming experience and graphical and musical styles characteristic of games of those decades.
-
- Posts: 873
- Joined: Thu Sep 11, 2014 3:37 pm
Re: Monitor without apparent scanlines
I don't remember anyone talking about scanlines until emulation became popular. I was more than your average gaming fan and I never heard the term until emulation on flatscreens. The reality is that as kids, we never looked for them but they were most certainly there if you did.fernan1234 wrote:Even on that arcade monitor scanlines look rather noticeable to me.
In any case, rather than how stuff looked like to us in the 80s or 90s, if time and budget allows I don't see why not go for the best possible picture quality attainable. The nostalgia does not reside on picture quality anyway, but on the gaming experience and graphical and musical styles characteristic of games of those decades.
I have old arcade boards and old arcade monitors here and you can easily see scanlines if you look for them and, the way the old boards look on screen is identical to what you get from Groovymame.
Scanlines are inevitable if you display a 240 line image on an SD display designed to display 480 lines. If you display. 480 line image on that same screen, scanlines will vanish.
The issue with the image on hd LCD displays is the scaling, not the lack of scanlines. Without a quality scaler, the effect is similar to taking a tiny thumb-nail jpeg image and zooming in until it fills your 1080p monitor - the larger it gets, the more pixelated it becomes. LCD panels have to scale 240p to their native res. CRTs switch res to match the source.
If you could find an LCD with a native res that matched your 240p game, it would look good.
Btw, The date on that Sony Trinitron that I posted pics of (showing scanlines through SVideo) is 1992.
-
- Posts: 629
- Joined: Sat Jan 07, 2017 5:11 pm
Re: Monitor without apparent scanlines
What does OP think about my "15 CRT TV on composite? It really has no scanlines. Please ignore the colors, it was very hard to take a good shot without the black bars covering up.
https://i.imgur.com/FJU0Ycy.jpg
https://i.imgur.com/FJU0Ycy.jpg
Re: Monitor without apparent scanlines
lol its apparent OP just loves old shadow mask/slot mask CRTs. Thats fine, but I want to torture him, so...
https://i.imgur.com/g1WCzs8.jpg
https://i.imgur.com/TOVKbAk.jpg
https://i.imgur.com/JpOvj1L.jpg
https://i.imgur.com/IHnN3zW.jpg
https://i.imgur.com/4hV49vC.jpg
https://i.imgur.com/0fpS4va.jpg
https://i.imgur.com/mqXRTba.jpg
https://i.imgur.com/6jxqPAA.jpg
https://i.imgur.com/0Un6x00.jpg
https://i.imgur.com/g1WCzs8.jpg
https://i.imgur.com/TOVKbAk.jpg
https://i.imgur.com/JpOvj1L.jpg
https://i.imgur.com/IHnN3zW.jpg
https://i.imgur.com/4hV49vC.jpg
https://i.imgur.com/0fpS4va.jpg
https://i.imgur.com/mqXRTba.jpg
https://i.imgur.com/6jxqPAA.jpg
https://i.imgur.com/0Un6x00.jpg
Re: Monitor without apparent scanlines
Keep ya filthy scanlines outta this thread.Josh128 wrote:lol its apparent OP just loves old shadow mask/slot mask CRTs. Thats fine, but I want to torture him, so...
That said, it's really surprising how well the plasma compares to a CRT with every third (line3x) blank.
Re: Monitor without apparent scanlines
Yeah it really does. The horizontal granularity of the 1024 horizontal res over 51" screen actually very closely mimics a nice consumer Trinitron. Thats why I was asking about it in the OSSC Pro thread. Had no idea this was possible on the OSSC.strayan wrote:Keep ya filthy scanlines outta this thread.Josh128 wrote:lol its apparent OP just loves old shadow mask/slot mask CRTs. Thats fine, but I want to torture him, so...
That said, it's really surprising how well the plasma compares to a CRT with every third (line3x) blank.