R79 wrote:Skykid, don't ever let people from Germany of all places lecture anyone about state oppression

Ha ha, I'm not, watch!
MintyTheCat wrote:
I find it amusing that Skykid sits in China telling me that I am influenced purely by propaganda when China silences even slight infractions from those who have any manner of issue with the state.
Absolute nonsense, people are constantly trashing government and ridiculing government officials (especially where money is concerned) all the time on social media. It's a constant string of memes and poking fun at the higher authorities, and nobody "disappears" for it. It's not 1971 any more.
To pander to your paranoia however, Chinese news media
is censored when it comes to certain major events that affect the country politically. Trying to get information on the Hong Kong protests was nigh-on impossible bar a few simple snippets of information, and I'll never defend that. Not ideal, but quickly resolved by a good VPN.
MintyTheCat wrote:
It is the conditions of a system that concern me; if you have free reign and no one can comment and you can pollute and let out whatever you wish to it is in my opinion endemic of a corrupt and unjust system.
Rubbish. You've polluted this thread more unjustly than China's government has polluted Beijing. Pollution in *select areas* of China has not occurred by choice but by poor management of an economic revolution that happened so quickly the paperwork and red tape literally wasn't in place. By this point it simply doesn't matter anyway, it's in the past and we're in the present. The point is: they recognise the problem and are working to fix it. My city has had a ban on petrol fuelled bikes for five years, so everyone is forced to use electric, precisely to improve air quality. And it works.
if you have free reign and no one can comment
Understanding the political system of China is fairly complicated and I genuinely don't think you're up to the task. You can't just wake up one morning and say "let's do a full blown western democracy!" when you have 1.4 billion people and a country in a state of massive economic flux - it doesn't work that way. Elements of Chinese government system work very well indeed, and if you ever needed proof of that just observe the annual GDP.
And before you start talking about communism like it's still the cold war, are you aware of the developments in East London regarding land sales? Cameron has sold council home land to private investors for redevelopment. Tens of thousands of residents have been forcefully displaced, long term communities broken down, and scattered into alternative housing in the far reaches where no-one will have to look at their poverty. The council estates have been levelled - the ones in Elephant & Castle and Clapham housed an enormous populace - and new build properties are going up in their wake.
Now: the tenants had no say, were given no voice, and no choice. And it wasn't in your news media, it wasn't on your TV, it wasn't even on the wind - it was done behind your back. It's actually a form of social cleansing by displacing the poor to allow the rich to move in and raise the profile of the neighbourhood.
Now if you want to talk about old-world
communism it doesn't get much better than that - the only caveat being it's the poor being displaced for the rich, and not vise-versa.
For the levels of pollution to be that high in Beijing
You are a broken fucking record and an embarrassment to your gene pool. Did you read any of the information that was given to you? Did you see the list of top 20 most polluted cities I gave you (because Beijing ain't on it) and did you question why you don't get news reports about the state of those other cities?
In fact, did you read
anything that I bothered to write out for you? What about Tiananmen Square, any comments or questions?
India too is experiencing the same issues: rapid expansion, poor policies in place to protect people's health, pollution, impacts your environment and in turn reduces your human capital as people become ill and die prematurely.
Looking forward to hearing you talk about that then, except you know very little about India, it's crises, it's government policies or its people, because it ain't in the news every second day.
I doubt I am anything near close to the level of extremism the chinese state would employ to silence dissenters.
Again, lots of psychological proofing and splitting at work.
You're living in a complete fantasy. Do you know how lawless China actually is? People do whatever they want. It drives me crazy sometimes. I recently commented that I wished the police would actually do more to enforce laws, because at the moment they're like roadside wallpaper. Nobody cares about whatever the next government or city law is, and if it even registers it's generally ignored. China needs more laws and more enforcement of those laws, and quickly. It would be a major improvement.
MintyTheCat wrote:POLLUTION, POLLUTION, EXPLOSIONS & POLLUTION
Yeah it's getting tiring now. I will finish on this one very poignant statement thought:
MintyTheCat wrote:So please, read what I have raised before you come along with your sweeping statements as that's the easiest thing in the world to do.
That's damn good advice, and I suggest you take it.