I mean, they are fine. But I wouldn't launch him into my favorite directors list. He's cool though.
Unpopular opinion I know

They Live is worth a go! Won't age, at least in our lifetimes, sadly. Legendary BACK ALLEY WEAPONS BEATDOWN from Messrs. Piper and David too.Sumez wrote: ↑Fri Mar 28, 2025 8:05 am I've really tried to like Carpenter, I feel like I should. And to be fair, I'm still missing a lot of his movies. But I've seen The Thing, Halloween, Big Trouble In Little China, and Escape From New York. And none of them really did anything for me.
I mean, they are fine. But I wouldn't launch him into my favorite directors list. He's cool though.
Unpopular opinion I know![]()
Spit it outsumdumgoy wrote: ↑Fri Mar 28, 2025 5:41 pmNothing wrong with that! The most important thing is that you're being honest about your response.Sumez wrote: ↑Fri Mar 28, 2025 8:05 am I've really tried to like Carpenter, I feel like I should. And to be fair, I'm still missing a lot of his movies. But I've seen The Thing, Halloween, Big Trouble In Little China, and Escape From New York. And none of them really did anything for me.
I mean, they are fine. But I wouldn't launch him into my favorite directors list. He's cool though.
Unpopular opinion I know![]()
Truth be told, I feel the same way about another idolized director held high by many vociferous fans, who are all sitting keyboard-ready to shame me for my supposed lack of knowledge and/or understanding of art every time I deride his name. And it's an opinion as unpopular as yours.
Not a Kubrick fan? Fine by me. But that "2" in your parenthesis means the # of films you've seen from him, and that's not the right #, correct?sumdumgoy wrote: ↑Fri Mar 28, 2025 7:07 pmHoo, boy... I dunno!Lord British wrote: ↑Fri Mar 28, 2025 5:43 pm Spit it out
It's not all about "hate". Sometimes it's just indifference.
I can make a list of directors I don't like or underappreciate. The only one I fucking hate is Christopher Nolan (except for Memento).
I was thinking of starting a thread on things in/about movies that you can't stand, and mine is movies done by directors who are more concerned with the rigid, technical side of filmmaking, rather than with characters or writing (where the latter is simply fodder to showcase the former). Those type of movies always leave me feeling cold and alienated, and if you dare honestly criticise the director's work with your response to it, you attract the ire of the 2-DEEP-4-U Klub that treats you like a dirty pleb. Their movies make me feel like I'm visiting a museum of modern art where it's like, "Okay, that's cool and all, and I can appreciate the hard work and the effort... but it feels more like a showcase for hosannas to the architect."
And regarding Nolan, you're not alone. I got a real buzz out of Memento when I was a teen, but once you get over the whole messed-chronology angle, his movies bore me. (I revisited it on the Criterion Channel last month, and I wasn't convinced.)Spoiler
You want me to say it? Really?Spoiler
Are you sure?! The monkey's paw beckons you!Spoiler
Stanley Kubrick (2) HL = The Killing (1956)
'
Except Following, that one's okay.
sumdumgoy wrote: ↑Fri Mar 28, 2025 7:17 pmAh, okay, I thought it meant the number of movies of his I enjoyed, lol.Lord British wrote: ↑Fri Mar 28, 2025 7:13 pm Not a Kubrick fan? Fine by me. But that "2" in your parenthesis means the # of films you've seen from him, and that's not the right #, correct?
The correct number for me would be 10.
Yes, the epic special effects were mind-blowing, especially just for the innovative "Slit-scan" warp effect scene alone with main character, David Bowman, inside the space pod vehicle itself warping to a mysterious destination unknown and later on, is finally revealed.sumdumgoy wrote: ↑Sat Mar 29, 2025 1:11 amAs my mom used to say,PC Engine Fan X! wrote: ↑Sat Mar 29, 2025 12:38 am For sumdumgoy,
What's your take/opinion on the classic sci-fi film of Stanley Kubrick's "2001"?"Yeah, classic snoozefest." Better to ask Lord British for his take instead. He's the Stanley fan.
Besides, it's not fresh in my mind, and I wanna stay in a good mood for my midnight revisit of Basket Case.![]()
The above article has a brief mention of the campy Hausu (aka House) that debuted back in 1977. What's your opinion on it, sumdumgoy? Not to mention that non-conjoined twins do have the ability to communicate telepathically and are able finish each others sentences if spoken verbally.sumdumgoy wrote: ↑Sat Mar 29, 2025 2:20 pm Basket Case (1982)
WHAT IS THE SECRET DUANE IS HIDING IN THE BASKET?
Spoiler
"Movies are so rarely great art, that if we cannot appreciate great trash, we have very little reason to be interested in them."
~ Pauline Kael | Trash, Art, and the Movies (1969)
Spawned from the depths of that notoriously seedy 42nd St. in New York City, Basket Case is a love letter by a grindhouse aficionado, for grindhouse aficionados. Director Frank Henenlotter grew up living the experience of those grungy moviehouses throughout the 1970s, each with their own distinct atmosphere and audience, lapping up one on-screen atrocity after another that was far from both the high art of cinema and safe Hollywood fare. Gratuitous nudity, BDSM romps, and buckets of blood & guts were not only served, but expected, with crowds turning hostile and pelting the screen with their drinks if what was up there didn't deliver on its poster promises.
The promise here is simple: Duane and Belial are siamese twins seeking revenge against the doctors who seperated them against their will and left the small, deformed one for dead. But to get to the rest, they have to travel to The Big Apple, and the only way they can do it safely is by keeping Belial in a conspicuously large wicker basket, prompting the question from everyone, "What's in the basket?"
At first, I feel like Duane does, a little disoriented from all the street garbage, neon lights, porno shops and movie theatres. These dilapidated settings with their perpetually lived-in feel are so actively unclean, I can practically smell them. And every person he comes across are such characters in themselves, not even a low-budget script can get in the way of their amusing personalities. (The movie leans into them for comic relief.) Well, at least the room at the Hotel Broslin ain't so bad. It's not home, but... it's a room.
Duane seems like such an innocent young man, coming down from Upstate on his first trip to New York, reacting to everything with a kind of subtle, but reasonable bewilderment; you believe him when he tells his date, Sharon, that he's mostly kept to himself. And when his new hotel neighbour Casey asks him what he does, he tells her he sorts letters, and she replies, "You're a mailman?!" and busts out laughing.
Later, we learn that, even though Duane and Belial were able to communicate telepathically while conjoined, after the surgeons seperated them against their will, Duane became no longer capable of communicating to Belial in that fashion... but Belial still can with him. (At least, this is what Duane admits over drinks with Casey.) This gives me the disturbing sensation that maybe, just maybe these thoughts of revenge aren't coming from this little demon, but might be the result of Duane's dual trama of his mother's death at their childbirth and the brothers unwilling seperation. And to add in another layer, in a flashback the dad cries out, "It killed its own mother!" leaving the suggestion that the mother's death from childbirth wasn't natural. "He always knows what I'm thinking," Duane says, and when Casey replies that he's giving her the creeps, it's not just her. "I don't know which one of us is worse," Duane replies.
And his "little" brother is somethin' else! Nothing Belial does belies his namesake, from the grunting, snorting and spitting while he eats (the basket shakes to his meals), to the ear-splitting shrieks, screams and reaction hissing to any given situation. He's a murderous demon with an insatiable appetite for destuction (evisceration being his specialty), and a lust to match his brother's (his pitovtal "love scene" with the cute & busty Terri Susan Smith is one that I'm sure BIL here would appreciate).
When it comes to exploitation, Basket Case delivers. What makes this movie doubly-strange is just how assured it is in its moviemaking. Every camera angle, every edit, every effect... this was directed by a guy who knew the genre inside and out, and filmed his movie like he already knew what to do. (As a fan, I know that impulse during a movie, where you think changes and edits in your mind to fix the bad movie you're watching and make it better.) Nothing can reasonably be argued against its competantcy, and it's a kind of marvel in itself that it came out feeling more expensive than it did! (The movie was completed on a paltry $35,000 budget.)
Like 1977's wild Japanese horror-comedy House, Basket Case swaggers along with a kind of unbelievable confidence that says, "Hey, world, here I am! Come with me, and let's have some fun." Trashy fun, yes, but that kind of hard-to-resist fun... like a hosed-down sow going back into the yard, it's hard for it not to side-eye that mud puddle, 'cause it knows how great it would feel to wallow in it for a bit!
As Kael pointed out in her essay, "There is so much talk now about the art of film that we may be in danger of forgetting that most of the movies we enjoy are not works of art... if we’ve grown up at the movies, we know that good work is continuous not with the academic, respectable tradition, but with the glimpses of something good in trash.... Trash has given us an appetite for art."
This is the litmus test to see if you have a soul or not. You maybe the only person here to ever fail.
RegalSin wrote:New PowerPuff Girls. They all have evil pornstart eyelashes.
RegalSin wrote:New PowerPuff Girls. They all have evil pornstart eyelashes.
Having gone to Orlando every year, and being a lifelong Floridian, it's the most accurate depiction of the state I've ever seen.GaijinPunch wrote: ↑Sun Mar 30, 2025 12:40 am The Florida Project
I downloaded this when it first came to streaming ages ago, and it expired. With all of the Oscar buzz around Sean Baker, I figured it would be good fodder for a flight. Willem Defoe plays a likeable, but visibly irritated, manager of a shit hole hotel in Florida, which has some extremely colorful inhabitants - including the world's worst mother, whom the story largely centers around. Touching in some ways, and despite being set in modern day, will take Gen-X'ers back to a time when kids could take adventures without the helicopter parents breathing down their necks. Not a pretty tale, and I'm pretty sure not a rare one either, sadly. Despite the serious tone, there are still some laughs, and the majority of it isn't too hard to watch.
heli wrote:Why is milestone director in prison ?, are his game to difficult ?
It felt a bit harsh for me to say that, but there was a voice back in my head saying, "there's a ton of parts of Florida where this shit is happening right now." Everywhere has their dumps - everywhere. I think what makes Florida special, is that they are at most a stone's throw from the tourist traps, so they're quite unavoidable if you go to Florida for just about any reason. I have friends in Miami and I go from time to time, and it's always pretty wild. Then again, I live in San Francisco and need to find a new place to live. My last was Nob Hill which is by all accounts a nice hood (and in fact, was traditionally the bougie part of town), but just 4-5 blocks from the Tenderloin - the likes of which I have never seen anywhere on the fucking planet, and I travel quite a bit. Ironically I don't feel it's that dangerous. I wouldn't walk through it as a woman but as a tall man, with a decent stride, it's not bothered me. However it is definitely not for the weak-stomached.cj iwakura wrote: ↑Sun Mar 30, 2025 1:32 pm Having gone to Orlando every year, and being a lifelong Floridian, it's the most accurate depiction of the state I've ever seen.
RegalSin wrote:New PowerPuff Girls. They all have evil pornstart eyelashes.
RegalSin wrote:New PowerPuff Girls. They all have evil pornstart eyelashes.
This has been on my watch-list since I saw Red Rocket earlier this year. What "streaming" were you able to find it on? I annoyingly haven't been able to dig up any other Sean Baker movies anywhere, but I nearly pulled the trigger on some blurays the other day.GaijinPunch wrote: ↑Sun Mar 30, 2025 12:40 am The Florida Project
I downloaded this when it first came to streaming ages ago, and it expired. With all of the Oscar buzz around Sean Baker, I figured it would be good fodder for a flight.
I'd know nothing w/o rock lyrics (Thanks Rancid)GaijinPunch wrote: ↑Sun Mar 30, 2025 3:30 pmIt felt a bit harsh for me to say that, but there was a voice back in my head saying, "there's a ton of parts of Florida where this shit is happening right now." Everywhere has their dumps - everywhere. I think what makes Florida special, is that they are at most a stone's throw from the tourist traps, so they're quite unavoidable if you go to Florida for just about any reason. I have friends in Miami and I go from time to time, and it's always pretty wild. Then again, I live in San Francisco and need to find a new place to live. My last was Nob Hill which is by all accounts a nice hood (and in fact, was traditionally the bougie part of town), but just 4-5 blocks from the Tenderloin - the likes of which I have never seen anywhere on the fucking planet, and I travel quite a bit. Ironically I don't feel it's that dangerous. I wouldn't walk through it as a woman but as a tall man, with a decent stride, it's not bothered me. However it is definitely not for the weak-stomached.cj iwakura wrote: ↑Sun Mar 30, 2025 1:32 pm Having gone to Orlando every year, and being a lifelong Floridian, it's the most accurate depiction of the state I've ever seen.
I was curious about how bad it was out there. Found a couple of YT reports about the place and....man. Well, I won't be going in person anytime soon! Makes me feel very lucky to be where I am. The whole notion of a "harm reduction" program by handing out needles and crackpipes, seems at best oxymoronic. Fentanyl is wiping out hundreds each year in that relatively small zone; a hundred times more potent than morphine.GaijinPunch wrote: ↑Sun Mar 30, 2025 3:30 pm...the Tenderloin - the likes of which I have never seen anywhere on the fucking planet, and I travel quite a bit. Ironically I don't feel it's that dangerous. I wouldn't walk through it as a woman but as a tall man, with a decent stride, it's not bothered me. However it is definitely not for the weak-stomached.cj iwakura wrote: ↑Sun Mar 30, 2025 1:32 pm Having gone to Orlando every year, and being a lifelong Floridian, it's the most accurate depiction of the state I've ever seen.
I'm all good thanks, just a very erratic and inconsistent poster (and film watcher!).
Check a local library, mine usually has it.Sumez wrote: ↑Mon Mar 31, 2025 5:29 amThis has been on my watch-list since I saw Red Rocket earlier this year. What "streaming" were you able to find it on? I annoyingly haven't been able to dig up any other Sean Baker movies anywhere, but I nearly pulled the trigger on some blurays the other day.GaijinPunch wrote: ↑Sun Mar 30, 2025 12:40 am The Florida Project
I downloaded this when it first came to streaming ages ago, and it expired. With all of the Oscar buzz around Sean Baker, I figured it would be good fodder for a flight.
heli wrote:Why is milestone director in prison ?, are his game to difficult ?
I think it's not hard to understand why Carpenter was considered a cult film auteur for so long. He has a very idiosyncratic style that either resonates with you or it doesn't. Not personally liking the aesthetic is a completely valid position, even if you can see that other people who's taste you respect or even admire do.Sumez wrote: ↑Fri Mar 28, 2025 8:05 am I've really tried to like Carpenter, I feel like I should. And to be fair, I'm still missing a lot of his movies. But I've seen The Thing, Halloween, Big Trouble In Little China, and Escape From New York. And none of them really did anything for me.
I mean, they are fine. But I wouldn't launch him into my favorite directors list. He's cool though.
Unpopular opinion I know![]()
I don't feel the pressure to like Carpenter as much as I do Cronenberg, he's been attributed moreso with that "Thinking Man's Horror Director" tag, so if you don't love it you're considered a dumbo. With Carpenter it's never a direct hit with me, but overall I enjoy his films. With Cronenberg it always feels like I'm missing something. Also, I almost always feel w/ DC that his films are too talky.vol.2 wrote: ↑Mon Mar 31, 2025 3:01 pmI think it's not hard to understand why Carpenter was considered a cult film auteur for so long. He has a very idiosyncratic style that either resonates with you or it doesn't. Not personally liking the aesthetic is a completely valid position, even if you can see that other people who's taste you respect or even admire do.Sumez wrote: ↑Fri Mar 28, 2025 8:05 am I've really tried to like Carpenter, I feel like I should. And to be fair, I'm still missing a lot of his movies. But I've seen The Thing, Halloween, Big Trouble In Little China, and Escape From New York. And none of them really did anything for me.
I mean, they are fine. But I wouldn't launch him into my favorite directors list. He's cool though.
Unpopular opinion I know![]()
I'm among the "love Carpenter" people, but I also was very primed on his movies early in my life at the time when his work was a more contemporaneous part of the zeitgeist. I absolutely do not expect everyone I meet and who's taste in movies I respect to like his stuff, and I think it's unfortunate that taste has to be wrapped up in a notion of "cool" or whatever. I wish we could all just appreciate and talk about this stuff without having to dance around all that BS.
heli wrote:Why is milestone director in prison ?, are his game to difficult ?