CMoon wrote:boagman wrote:
*WOW* do I ever disagree with you. I like SST for sure, but better than T2? Not a stinking chance. Cameron being washed out at the point of T2? I'm not sure how much *more* I could disagree with you. While Cameron has certainly slipped since then...he was still kicking tail and taking names with T2.
Didn't see this one, so sorry for the delayed response. My issue with T2 versus the previous films is
a softening of the tone. Certainly Cameron is
a more competent director by this point, but as I said previously, the bite is gone. Arnie is instructed not to kill people. When he rips the skin off his arm, despite the better effects, it isn't even gory. Compare this to the mood in T1 where regardless of limitations in budget and special effects, the film just feels so much more raw, dangerous and gorey.
It isn't like we haven't seen this pattern before. Look what happened to Spielberg in the early 80's. We're all welcome to have opinions, and I don't see any problem with liking T2 more than T1, and I think on
a lot of technical levels it IS
a better film. So disagreeing with me is fine; but for me it isn't
a more effective film and actually fails to capture the rather horrific vision of the first Terminator. It also signifies where I start losing interest in Cameron, because despite his incredible technical ability, Aliens is the last film where I feel like he is something more than just
a big hollywood director.
I can totally understand what you're saying, and have no problem with the idea that T1 is more "raw" than T2 is. We're in complete agreement on that point. I'd say that T2 was the pinnacle of Cameron's stuff...after that, he became too much the Hollywood-y guy, and his material suffered
a bit after it, falling *hard* in recent years. He's still the absolute freaking *master* of whizbangery, though: while "Avatar" was just an *awful* movie, the special effects were pretty much just mind-blowing. I can't hate the movie that makes my jaw drop in wonder...but I can hate its script with
a vengeance with no problem whatsoever.
My biggest wince with your statement was the "SST is better than T2" thing. I just do not get that...*at all*. Don't get me wrong: SST is
a nice little romp with
a decent story and goofy characters, and I've certainly watched it multiple times (can't say that for any of its sequels, though...not sure SST was *that* good), but to these eyes and ears, it doesn't hold
a candle to T2 in just about any area, save for maybe chick skin or something minor like that. As far as script, characters, special effects, and yes: direction? Again: I like SST. T2, though? That's ridiculously good stuff IMHO.
BTW, T1 and Aliens are fantastic, yes. I'm prone to agree with your point about Spielberg, too. It's
a reasonable observation.