Dreamcast official VGA box
-
- Posts: 707
- Joined: Sun Aug 21, 2016 5:18 pm
Re: Dreamcast official VGA box
There's also a brightness control on the Toro, don't know if that actually helps with anything though.
Re: Dreamcast official VGA box
I think that's more like a bug labelled as a feature. Just seems to add a grey overlay to the whole image.thebigcheese wrote:There's also a brightness control on the Toro, don't know if that actually helps with anything though.
-
andykara2003
- Posts: 1338
- Joined: Sat Apr 27, 2013 3:26 pm
Re: Dreamcast official VGA box
Interesting - it’s funny because the Dreamcast's VGA output has always been viewed as impeccable by the retro community in the past.クリスチャン wrote:Looks like the Dreamcast DAC is not that great. Boosted levels, slightly noisy video, and slightly uneven colors.
Re: Dreamcast official VGA box
na, maybe in terms of sharpness (and that's a valid statement even today), but the fact that the video levels are overblown has been known for ages.
-
andykara2003
- Posts: 1338
- Joined: Sat Apr 27, 2013 3:26 pm
Re: Dreamcast official VGA box
Ahh OK, I hadn't picked up on that, good to know.
Re: Dreamcast official VGA box
If you use 480i instead of 480p, do you still have issues with overblown video levels and RGB levels or those issues only affect 480p?maxtherabbit wrote:I would wait until the RGC cable is actually released before dismissing it
-
maxtherabbit
- Posts: 1763
- Joined: Mon Mar 05, 2018 4:03 pm
Re: Dreamcast official VGA box
I have not tested 480i specifically, but the issues are the same on 240p - so I would say yes they affect all modesLawfer wrote:If you use 480i instead of 480p, do you still have issues with overblown video levels and RGB levels or those issues only affect 480p?maxtherabbit wrote:I would wait until the RGC cable is actually released before dismissing it
Re: Dreamcast official VGA box
Honestly the vast majority of this information is not widely known. It's not like how most people in the retro scene know about 1 chip SNES vs 2 chip. This is especially true regarding the whole aspect ratio and sampling thing. That issue wasn't "widely" exposed until the OSSC came about, and even Digital Foundry missed some info about what exactly is different with the DC's VGA output. They just mentioned sample rate; which is only half of the story.andykara2003 wrote:Ahh OK, I hadn't picked up on that, good to know.
For whatever reason the DC just doesn't get enough coverage on these things.
-
- Posts: 386
- Joined: Sun Jul 04, 2010 11:14 pm
Re: Dreamcast official VGA box
Can someone test a cga/vga converter on the DC just to help me confirm something?
"Don't HD my SD!!"
-
maxtherabbit
- Posts: 1763
- Joined: Mon Mar 05, 2018 4:03 pm
Re: Dreamcast official VGA box
The gbs8200? Yeah I just got mineheadlesshobbs wrote:Can someone test a cga/vga converter on the DC just to help me confirm something?
-
- Posts: 386
- Joined: Sun Jul 04, 2010 11:14 pm
Re: Dreamcast official VGA box
So now that I got some of my equipment in order, I decided to so a little test to find out what devices the DC has a problem with.
Test game - SoulCalibur/Sophitia Stage
Monoprice VGA to HDMI Converter - Fail
(No Name) HD Video Converter - Pass
CGA/VGA Converter - Pass
Open Source Scan Converter - Adjust to 6-7 Pass
Direct connection to PC CRT - Pass
Direct connection to LCD/LED (past test) - Fail
The one's that fail is where the issue on accepting the analog conversion is being done improperly. I know the levels are high for it's output, but in the past I've never seen this problem until digital came along and even with PC systems at the normal settings, I've experienced the wrong level of contrast saturation being applied. This is a note on all who are in the business of making analog/digital converters to monitor their calibration settings as the problem lies with them and not just a single gaming console alone. (This test is 10+ years old btw)
Test game - SoulCalibur/Sophitia Stage
Monoprice VGA to HDMI Converter - Fail
(No Name) HD Video Converter - Pass
CGA/VGA Converter - Pass
Open Source Scan Converter - Adjust to 6-7 Pass
Direct connection to PC CRT - Pass
Direct connection to LCD/LED (past test) - Fail
The one's that fail is where the issue on accepting the analog conversion is being done improperly. I know the levels are high for it's output, but in the past I've never seen this problem until digital came along and even with PC systems at the normal settings, I've experienced the wrong level of contrast saturation being applied. This is a note on all who are in the business of making analog/digital converters to monitor their calibration settings as the problem lies with them and not just a single gaming console alone. (This test is 10+ years old btw)
"Don't HD my SD!!"
Re: Dreamcast official VGA box
If you absolutely must buy a standalone ADC, hunt down some higher quality gear. Chinese stuff sucks.
Extron DVC RGB-HD A does a good job. It also recognizes and samples the Dreamcast aspect ratio properly.
In addition to ADC, it brings low pass filtering and EDID management with a PC.
Extron DVC RGB-HD A does a good job. It also recognizes and samples the Dreamcast aspect ratio properly.
In addition to ADC, it brings low pass filtering and EDID management with a PC.
We apologise for the inconvenience
Re: Dreamcast official VGA box
I just assumed they were referring to the fuckery that a modern display does to a Dreamcast's wider-than-normal VGA signal. No?maxtherabbit wrote:the official VGA box buffers H/V sync through a 74HCT244 and contains coupling caps for RGB
the toro does not contain any scaling logic, so I'm not sure where they are getting "pixel scaling issues" from - that really makes no sense
-
maxtherabbit
- Posts: 1763
- Joined: Mon Mar 05, 2018 4:03 pm
Re: Dreamcast official VGA box
probably, but why try to put that on the box? ANY RGB or VGA output solution is going to do the same thingEndymion wrote:I just assumed they were referring to the fuckery that a modern display does to a Dreamcast's wider-than-normal VGA signal. No?maxtherabbit wrote:the official VGA box buffers H/V sync through a 74HCT244 and contains coupling caps for RGB
the toro does not contain any scaling logic, so I'm not sure where they are getting "pixel scaling issues" from - that really makes no sense
Re: Dreamcast official VGA box
It didn't seem to me they were putting it on the box, it's just the case that if you use the thing with an HDTV you'll have that kind of weirdness yeah? I don't know that the Toro was really marketed to anything but die-hard CRT gamers, but there's always going to be someone wanting to plug something like that up to their brand new OLED or whatever. And it's a natural point to make if you are comparing it with the DCHDMI particularly.
-
maxtherabbit
- Posts: 1763
- Joined: Mon Mar 05, 2018 4:03 pm
Re: Dreamcast official VGA box
obviously it was misleading, since a couple people in this very thread were believing that the official VGA box from sega behaved differently in that regardEndymion wrote:It didn't seem to me they were putting it on the box, it's just the case that if you use the thing with an HDTV you'll have that kind of weirdness yeah? I don't know that the Toro was really marketed to anything but die-hard CRT gamers, but there's always going to be someone wanting to plug something like that up to their brand new OLED or whatever. And it's a natural point to make if you are comparing it with the DCHDMI particularly.
Re: Dreamcast official VGA box
The ability of the Toro to output 31KHz RGBS over the SCART connector means it's the only all-in-one solution to hook up the DC to a Framemeister. I know this was an intentional marketing decision on their part because Beharbros sent me a free Toro so I could test it with my Framemeister.Endymion wrote:I don't know that the Toro was really marketed to anything but die-hard CRT gamers
-
- Posts: 1974
- Joined: Wed Jul 19, 2017 1:52 pm
Re: Dreamcast official VGA box
Not quite. The Toro is the only solution that is always readily-available for purchase. thefoo.83 on eBay has made Dreamcast SCART cables with a mode switch that will produce 480p, just like the Toro, but without the fuss or obnoxious depth added to the footprint of the console.darcagn wrote:The ability of the Toro to output 31KHz RGBS over the SCART connector means it's the only all-in-one solution to hook up the DC to a Framemeister. I know this was an intentional marketing decision on their part because Beharbros sent me a free Toro so I could test it with my Framemeister.
Re: Dreamcast official VGA box
Have to agree with this, I pretty much gave up on the Toro because it was such a pain to keep it all wired up without something coming disconnected or falling down the back of my shelves, or the connector cable breaking. It's an unnecessarily large box on the end of a fairly rigid, yet incredibly fragile cable, and connectors coming out of the sides at annoying angles.nmalinoski wrote:obnoxious depth added to the footprint of the console.
Re: Dreamcast official VGA box
nmalinoski wrote:Not quite. The Toro is the only solution that is always readily-available for purchase. thefoo.83 on eBay has made Dreamcast SCART cables with a mode switch that will produce 480p, just like the Toro, but without the fuss or obnoxious depth added to the footprint of the console.darcagn wrote:The ability of the Toro to output 31KHz RGBS over the SCART connector means it's the only all-in-one solution to hook up the DC to a Framemeister. I know this was an intentional marketing decision on their part because Beharbros sent me a free Toro so I could test it with my Framemeister.
Well yeah, anyone can make their own custom cables. Before the Toro or thefoo.83 were doing it I made one and published the schematic. He might even be using my schematic as a reference, who knows.
-
- Posts: 707
- Joined: Sun Aug 21, 2016 5:18 pm
Re: Dreamcast official VGA box
And RGC has one coming out soon.
-
- Posts: 484
- Joined: Wed Jun 22, 2005 9:20 am
- Location: Liberal cesspool
Re: Dreamcast official VGA box
Thank you for the tip regarding the output being too high. I was able to desolder the leg of each of the 220uf capacitors in the official VGA box and put a 20ohm resistor tied to each capacitor legs (capacitors turned on their sides). Output is perfect now and not all blown out.Konsolkongen wrote:It does, but adding a very small resistor to each of the RGB lines will solve this completely. I think I settled on about 10 ohms on mine.Gunstar wrote: Interesting that the official SEGA box blows out some details going by those comparison shots.
Edit: DF article with comparison
My experience with other brands of VGA boxes (one of the old transparant ones) does indeed confirm what Digital Foundry says. Years ago I ran my Dreamcast through a Gefen DVI Scaler exclusively and I was only able to get pixel perfect scaling using the original box from Sega.
A camel is a horse designed by a committee
-
- Posts: 484
- Joined: Wed Jun 22, 2005 9:20 am
- Location: Liberal cesspool
Re: Dreamcast official VGA box
Follow up post - seems the resistor mod disturbed the impedance of the output and now I have ghosting...
A camel is a horse designed by a committee
-
Konsolkongen
- Posts: 2315
- Joined: Fri May 16, 2008 8:28 pm
- Location: Denmark
Re: Dreamcast official VGA box
Is it possible to take a picture of this? I haven’t noticed anything like that on mine, but I can take a look if I have something to compare against.thchardcore wrote:Follow up post - seems the resistor mod disturbed the impedance of the output and now I have ghosting...
-
bobrocks95
- Posts: 3472
- Joined: Mon Apr 30, 2012 2:27 am
- Location: Kentucky
Re: Dreamcast official VGA box
Will hop onto this to comment again that good VGA solutions remain scarce for the Dreamcast. Most recently made cables are SCART focused which is a shame for a console that natively generates HV sync.
Has anybody tried the DC2VGA board from Jeff Chen? https://github.com/jeffqchen/DC2VGA
Just caps, resistors, and some XOR gates so it's going to require the same OSSC pre-ADC tweaks I figure. But onboard CSync seems relatively compatible and I'd be interested to try the Dreamcast plugged into the OSSC's AV1 to see if LPF helps with my image problems.
Has anybody tried the DC2VGA board from Jeff Chen? https://github.com/jeffqchen/DC2VGA
Just caps, resistors, and some XOR gates so it's going to require the same OSSC pre-ADC tweaks I figure. But onboard CSync seems relatively compatible and I'd be interested to try the Dreamcast plugged into the OSSC's AV1 to see if LPF helps with my image problems.
PS1 Disc-Based Game ID BIOS patch for MemCard Pro and SD2PSX automatic VMC switching.
Re: Dreamcast official VGA box
There's a similar device from Chipnetics too, the 'DreamBaby'
No mention of the hot RGB levels though, so I assume it's similar to Jeff's boardPurists will note that Dreamcast does output Csync on the AV Multi-out on pin 10; however this specific CSync signal is generated from an encoder (and not via the GPU) resulting in a significantly degraded image, compared to that from a sync combiner. Also this specific Csync signal is disabled in 31Khz mode!
-
- Posts: 484
- Joined: Wed Jun 22, 2005 9:20 am
- Location: Liberal cesspool
Re: Dreamcast official VGA box
Sure. Noticeable on the text of the GDEMU screen.Konsolkongen wrote:Is it possible to take a picture of this? I haven’t noticed anything like that on mine, but I can take a look if I have something to compare against.thchardcore wrote:Follow up post - seems the resistor mod disturbed the impedance of the output and now I have ghosting...
A camel is a horse designed by a committee
-
bobrocks95
- Posts: 3472
- Joined: Mon Apr 30, 2012 2:27 am
- Location: Kentucky
Re: Dreamcast official VGA box
Nice to see another option. It sounds like the CSync is generated in the same way ("Premium sync-combiner transistor" = an XOR gate, right?). I don't like the exposed PCB or the jumper for 15/31kHz though, a switch is preferable for the games you can trick into 480p by swapping between them.Gunstar wrote:There's a similar device from Chipnetics too, the 'DreamBaby'
No mention of the hot RGB levels though, so I assume it's similar to Jeff's boardPurists will note that Dreamcast does output Csync on the AV Multi-out on pin 10; however this specific CSync signal is generated from an encoder (and not via the GPU) resulting in a significantly degraded image, compared to that from a sync combiner. Also this specific Csync signal is disabled in 31Khz mode!
PS1 Disc-Based Game ID BIOS patch for MemCard Pro and SD2PSX automatic VMC switching.
-
- Posts: 484
- Joined: Wed Jun 22, 2005 9:20 am
- Location: Liberal cesspool
Re: Dreamcast official VGA box
A camel is a horse designed by a committee
-
Konsolkongen
- Posts: 2315
- Joined: Fri May 16, 2008 8:28 pm
- Location: Denmark
Re: Dreamcast official VGA box
I don’t have a GD Emu in my Dreamcast. Is it visible in the BIOS?