Conservatively modding a JPN Model1 Megadrive (VA4)

The place for all discussion on gaming hardware
Post Reply
User avatar
TheShadowRunner
Posts: 273
Joined: Sun Feb 24, 2013 7:41 pm

Conservatively modding a JPN Model1 Megadrive (VA4)

Post by TheShadowRunner »

Hey all,
I would like to mod a Japanese model1 Megadrive VA4 by doing the least amount of changes to the system (and none to the shell).
Ie, I would like to re-use the Din8 output and also keep the front headphone jack in working order (even if signal to noise ratio is pretty bad on this one).

For Audio I found an official mod by Akinori Nishiyama (WORKS NISHI), that can be seen here:

Image

On this page, a user does this mod by replacing:

Image

- the "+5V" on Pin4 of the Din8 by the "Left audio" channel.
- the "Mono sound" on Pin1 of the Din8 by "Right audio" channel
Now my question is the following: I see many solutions for MD audio called "Mega Amp", a project by FirebrandX, etc..
Is this "official" method by WORKS NISHI flawed in any way? If not, why isn't it the prefered method for restoring Stereo on model 1s?
I'm mainly concerned about the sound volume level after doing this mod. If it's on par with the original Mono volume level on the Din8 it'll be fine enough for me.

----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

For Video of course my goal is clean RGB, for it to work on both my BVM and XRGB Mini, hopefully without jailbars.
First I got an official Euro Sega RGB cable (R.V.B adaptor model 3085) and applied the mod from this french page to make it compatible with my JPN MD (which in a nutshell involves replacing the SYNC signal by the CVBS signal on input).

Image
Image

Then I realised it was completely silly because I DO want to use CSYNC rather than CVBS, since it apparently removes (most of) the jailbars.
And so I stumbled upon a mystery: Pin7 of the Din8 is supposed to carry SYNC on Japanese MDs but apparently Sega screwed up and connected Pin7 to "CSync in" (pin10 of the CXA1145) instead of "Csync out" (pin11 of the CXA1145).
And by checking my VA4 it certainly seems true, pin11 seems connected to nothing..
However it seems that this isn't a real issue?
Would anyone know if on JPN VA4 the SYNC signal coming out from Din8 is usable at all?
As is, meaning with "Sync in" wired instead of "Sync out" on Din8 Pin7 because of Sega's mistake, does the Sync line also need a 220uF cap + 75ohm resistor to work properly?

Apparently also the Model 3085 mod from that french page isn't even necessary, as another user proposes to keep using the SYNC signal on input but to remove resitor R19 for proper SYNC on NTSC systems.
If so, I would just restore the SYNC trace that I cut on my modded Model 3085, remove the R19 resistor (and possibly add a 220uF cap + 75ohm resistor instead) and call it a day?
Thanks for any input, thoughts, etc.. ^^
Last edited by TheShadowRunner on Tue Mar 12, 2019 6:16 pm, edited 1 time in total.
hellbelly
Posts: 100
Joined: Sat Sep 20, 2008 6:24 pm
Location: UK
Contact:

Re: Conservatively modding a JPN Model1 Megadrive (VA4)

Post by hellbelly »

From watching the weekly videos (weekly roundup and supporter q&a) on RetroRGB.com over the last few months, I believe that there is a decent RGB bypass for the MD, the model 1’s have had mixed success from it but I think that it is close to being resolved now.

That might be your best bet for video, I don’t know about using the official cable with the bypass mod though - I imagine someone will say get a new cable from Retro Gaming Cables or Retro Access depending your yours or their preferences/opinion.

I love the model 1 Japanese MD, great looks!
User avatar
TheShadowRunner
Posts: 273
Joined: Sun Feb 24, 2013 7:41 pm

Re: Conservatively modding a JPN Model1 Megadrive (VA4)

Post by TheShadowRunner »

hellbelly wrote:From watching the weekly videos (weekly roundup and supporter q&a) on RetroRGB.com over the last few months, I believe that there is a decent RGB bypass for the MD, the model 1’s have had mixed success from it but I think that it is close to being resolved now.

That might be your best bet for video, I don’t know about using the official cable with the bypass mod though - I imagine someone will say get a new cable from Retro Gaming Cables or Retro Access depending your yours or their preferences/opinion.

I love the model 1 Japanese MD, great looks!
Thanks for your input, I'm not interested in a full RGB bypass, I think it's unnecessary when we have everything on board already (again I'm aiming for the less amount of modding necessary).
But I think you were the one who found out about the sync-in/sync-out oddity.
To go further on this subject, would you remember if Pin10 of the CXA (sync in) connected to Pin7 of the Din8 (the original but apparently flawed design by Sega) was totally unusable?
Retro Access seem to say that it was actually working for her...?
So I wonder if you actually tried to add the "220uF cap + 75ohm resistor" to it (unmodified pin7 of the Din8) before you resorted to using Pin11 (sync out) of the CXA?
And yeah JPN MD looks the best ;)
nmalinoski
Posts: 1974
Joined: Wed Jul 19, 2017 1:52 pm

Re: Conservatively modding a JPN Model1 Megadrive (VA4)

Post by nmalinoski »

TheShadowRunner wrote:I would like to mod a Japanese model1 Megadrive VA4 by doing the least amount of changes to the system (and none to the shell).
Ie, I would like to re-use the Din8 output and also keep the front headphone jack in working order (even if signal to noise ratio is pretty bad on this one).
...
On this page, a user does this mod by replacing:
...
- the "+5V" on Pin4 of the Din8 by the "Left audio" channel.
- the "Mono sound" on Pin1 of the Din8 by "Right audio" channel
If I'm following this correctly, this stereo "restoration" mod changes the pinout of the existing 8-pin DIN?

Why do that, which will require custom cabling and potentially interfere with normal operation with a standard Genesis 1 cable, when you could fit the console with the kind of 9-pin DIN from the Genesis 2/3/32X/Nomad? I'm not sure what'd be involved as far as wiring goes, but that would get you what you want overall--stereo, no shell modifications--and you'd be able to properly use standard, off-the-shelf Genesis-2-compliant cables, including the HD Retrovision YPbPr cables.
hellbelly
Posts: 100
Joined: Sat Sep 20, 2008 6:24 pm
Location: UK
Contact:

Re: Conservatively modding a JPN Model1 Megadrive (VA4)

Post by hellbelly »

aha, apologies - didn't see the bit about least amount of modding necessary.

It was a long long time ago that I messed around with my MD, I don't remember 100% - I *think* I didn't try adding 220uF cap + 75ohm resistor to unmodified pin7 of the Din8

Hmm. Now I want a real japanese model 1 again!
User avatar
TheShadowRunner
Posts: 273
Joined: Sun Feb 24, 2013 7:41 pm

Re: Conservatively modding a JPN Model1 Megadrive (VA4)

Post by TheShadowRunner »

nmalinoski wrote:
TheShadowRunner wrote:I would like to mod a Japanese model1 Megadrive VA4 by doing the least amount of changes to the system (and none to the shell).
Ie, I would like to re-use the Din8 output and also keep the front headphone jack in working order (even if signal to noise ratio is pretty bad on this one).
...
On this page, a user does this mod by replacing:
...
- the "+5V" on Pin4 of the Din8 by the "Left audio" channel.
- the "Mono sound" on Pin1 of the Din8 by "Right audio" channel
If I'm following this correctly, this stereo "restoration" mod changes the pinout of the existing 8-pin DIN?

Why do that, which will require custom cabling and potentially interfere with normal operation with a standard Genesis 1 cable, when you could fit the console with the kind of 9-pin DIN from the Genesis 2/3/32X/Nomad? I'm not sure what'd be involved as far as wiring goes, but that would get you what you want overall--stereo, no shell modifications--and you'd be able to properly use standard, off-the-shelf Genesis-2-compliant cables, including the HD Retrovision YPbPr cables.
Yes it does change the pinout, I plan to do the same as the japanese modder, sacrifice +5v I'll never be using.
It's also much easier to rewire 2 pins on the existing DIN8 than reinvent the wheel by switching to a DIN9 imho (which come to think of it might be just impossible to swap on a model 1).
For audio, I just would like confirmation that the "official" mod's volume level matches that of the original Mono output, or at least that it isn't too low.
User avatar
TheShadowRunner
Posts: 273
Joined: Sun Feb 24, 2013 7:41 pm

Re: Conservatively modding a JPN Model1 Megadrive (VA4)

Post by TheShadowRunner »

hellbelly wrote:aha, apologies - didn't see the bit about least amount of modding necessary.

It was a long long time ago that I messed around with my MD, I don't remember 100% - I *think* I didn't try adding 220uF cap + 75ohm resistor to unmodified pin7 of the Din8

Hmm. Now I want a real japanese model 1 again!
Roger that. Hmm I wonder if anyone tried.. I think Fudoh also has a JPN M1 VA4 and used CSYNC as-is (Csync in / Pin 10) without modification.
nmalinoski
Posts: 1974
Joined: Wed Jul 19, 2017 1:52 pm

Re: Conservatively modding a JPN Model1 Megadrive (VA4)

Post by nmalinoski »

TheShadowRunner wrote:Yes it does change the pinout, I plan to do the same as the japanese modder, sacrifice +5v I'll never be using.
It's also much easier to rewire 2 pins on the existing DIN8 than reinvent the wheel by switching to a DIN9 imho (which come to think of it might be just impossible to swap on a model 1).
For audio, I just would like confirmation that the "official" mod's volume level matches that of the original Mono output, or at least that it isn't too low.
You might be able to get away without desoldering the 8-pin DIN, but you'll still need to snip those two pins to disconnect the old mono and 5V. (Or cut the traces, but that'd be worse.)

And no, I don't think you can directly swap the 9-pin DIN for the 8-pin. There is, of course, that 9th pin, which I mentioned would need to be snipped; and it's possible that the other pins won't line up or won't correspond to the same pins as on the Genesis 2/3/etc.

Should that be the case (the pinout not matching), you could very well mount the new socket upside-down--desolder old socket, solder wires for RGBS/CVBS/5V/ground on bottom of PCB, clean/flatten top surface, insulate the AV vias with with a layer of kapton tape, solder inverted 9-pin DIN to anchor points, solder AV wires to pins of new socket. Yeah, it's be more involved, but the result would be just as outwardly-clean, you wouldn't have to snip or cut anything, and, as I said, it would be more compatible with existing cables than modifying the pinout.
User avatar
TheShadowRunner
Posts: 273
Joined: Sun Feb 24, 2013 7:41 pm

Re: Conservatively modding a JPN Model1 Megadrive (VA4)

Post by TheShadowRunner »

nmalinoski wrote:
TheShadowRunner wrote:Yes it does change the pinout, I plan to do the same as the japanese modder, sacrifice +5v I'll never be using.
It's also much easier to rewire 2 pins on the existing DIN8 than reinvent the wheel by switching to a DIN9 imho (which come to think of it might be just impossible to swap on a model 1).
For audio, I just would like confirmation that the "official" mod's volume level matches that of the original Mono output, or at least that it isn't too low.
You might be able to get away without desoldering the 8-pin DIN, but you'll still need to snip those two pins to disconnect the old mono and 5V. (Or cut the traces, but that'd be worse.)

And no, I don't think you can directly swap the 9-pin DIN for the 8-pin. There is, of course, that 9th pin, which I mentioned would need to be snipped; and it's possible that the other pins won't line up or won't correspond to the same pins as on the Genesis 2/3/etc.

Should that be the case (the pinout not matching), you could very well mount the new socket upside-down--desolder old socket, solder wires for RGBS/CVBS/5V/ground on bottom of PCB, clean/flatten top surface, insulate the AV vias with with a layer of kapton tape, solder inverted 9-pin DIN to anchor points, solder AV wires to pins of new socket. Yeah, it's be more involved, but the result would be just as outwardly-clean, you wouldn't have to snip or cut anything, and, as I said, it would be more compatible with existing cables than modifying the pinout.
Thanks for the extended procedure, I'll keep it in my mind should I go the DIN replacement way, although I'd like to avoid it if possible.
Now I hope MD audio gurus (FBX..) can chime in regarding the audio quality / volume level of this "official" mod before I proceed further.
User avatar
FBX
Posts: 2347
Joined: Wed Feb 18, 2015 10:18 am
Location: DFW area, Texas
Contact:

Re: Conservatively modding a JPN Model1 Megadrive (VA4)

Post by FBX »

Okay, so what you have going on here is the Japanese mod is simply a variant of the 'Straight tap' Stereo audio mod. And what this is is tapping pins 1 and 8 of the stock op-amp chip. Now in the Japanese diagram, they show the chip orientated with 1 and 8 on the south side. In reality (at least on the Genesis models I've seen), this chip is actually rotated 180 degrees such that pins 1 and 8 are on the north side. I notice the Japanese mod also includes series polarized 4.7uF caps on each line. These are likely just safety caps, and the typical 'straight tap' mod doesn't include these.

With all that said, My own approach would be to leave the 8-pin DIN alone and instead remove the RF Box. Then do the upside-down 9-pin DIN trick where you remove some solder mask on the board where the RF box used to be, and solder the 9-pin DIN upside down to it using the metal housing for grounding it to the motherboard. Then from there, get a 9-pin DIN breakout board from here:

https://oshpark.com/shared_projects/37rGIZ8P

And this gives you freedom to wire each line, whether you want to use stock, RGB bypass, straight-tap stereo audio, or crystal clear audio amp (M1 Mini Mega, Mega Amp, etc.).

It's a reversible mod that you could always put the RF box back in if you wanted to restore the console to a stock appearance. Furthermore, you get the benefit of not needing custom cabling. A simple 9-pin Genesis model 2 cable will work, such as those made by HD Retrovision for component video, or RGB SCART made by Retro-Access.

As for the quality of the straight tap mod, it's barely any better than the headphone output. If you want a real noticed difference in quality, you need to go the next level and bypass the pre-amp and op-amp with a Mega Amp style board. My own version of this is on my web site here with full installation instructions (instead of RCA jacks, you would just hook the lines into the breakout board on the 9-pin DIN):

http://www.firebrandx.com/m1minimegakit.html
User avatar
Link83
Posts: 342
Joined: Tue May 21, 2013 2:39 am

Re: Conservatively modding a JPN Model1 Megadrive (VA4)

Post by Link83 »

Its my understanding that the French Sega SCART cable (Model 3085 "ADAPTEUR R.V.B.") is only intended to be used with French Master System 1/2 and Mega Drive 1 consoles. From what I read the French systems dont have buffered/amplified RGB signals available on the DIN8 port - internally the RGB signals connect directly to the VDP chip and they dont even have any video encoder chips on the motherboard (Sega continued this on all French DIN8 systems, and only changed when they switched to the DIN9 connector with the Mega Drive 2)

The components included in the Sega 3085's box to buffer/amplify the RGB signals on French consoles are definitely not the correct components specified in the video encoder datasheets used in Mega Drive 1's from outside of France, which typically have the DIN8 ports connected to the video encoders RGB output. However what effect this RGB 'double buffering' will have on the video quality (When using the French 3085 SCART cable on a Japanese Mega Drive) I cant say...
Last edited by Link83 on Wed Mar 13, 2019 6:14 pm, edited 3 times in total.
User avatar
ApolloBoy
Posts: 938
Joined: Sat Jan 28, 2012 7:17 pm
Location: San Jose, CA

Re: Conservatively modding a JPN Model1 Megadrive (VA4)

Post by ApolloBoy »

FBX wrote:With all that said, My own approach would be to leave the 8-pin DIN alone and instead remove the RF Box.
The Japanese Mega Drive doesn't have an internal RF modulator.
User avatar
TheShadowRunner
Posts: 273
Joined: Sun Feb 24, 2013 7:41 pm

Re: Conservatively modding a JPN Model1 Megadrive (VA4)

Post by TheShadowRunner »

ApolloBoy wrote:
FBX wrote:With all that said, My own approach would be to leave the 8-pin DIN alone and instead remove the RF Box.
The Japanese Mega Drive doesn't have an internal RF modulator.
Yes it doesn't! Besides my approach is to leave the shell intact, I don't care about (heavily) modifying the Model 3085 "ADAPTEUR R.V.B." though.
FBX wrote: As for the quality of the straight tap mod, it's barely any better than the headphone output. If you want a real noticed difference in quality, you need to go the next level and bypass the pre-amp and op-amp with a Mega Amp style board. My own version of this is on my web site here with full installation instructions (instead of RCA jacks, you would just hook the lines into the breakout board on the 9-pin DIN):

http://www.firebrandx.com/m1minimegakit.html
Hmm barely any better, Ok, but in terms of volume level, would you say it's comparable to the original Mono output?
Then there's this mod (thanks Fudoh / Konsolkongen):

Image

which seems to recreate for the Right channel the same op amp used for the original Mono signal.
Of course it's not on par with the quality delivered by your Mega Amp board, but it seems satisfactory enough... I wonder.
Last edited by TheShadowRunner on Thu Mar 14, 2019 1:14 am, edited 1 time in total.
User avatar
TheShadowRunner
Posts: 273
Joined: Sun Feb 24, 2013 7:41 pm

Re: Conservatively modding a JPN Model1 Megadrive (VA4)

Post by TheShadowRunner »

Link83 wrote:Its my understanding that the French Sega SCART cable (Model 3085 "ADAPTEUR R.V.B.") is only intended to be used with French Master System 1/2 and Mega Drive 1 consoles. From what I read the French systems dont have buffered/amplified RGB signals available on the DIN8 port - internally the RGB signals connect directly to the VDP chip and they dont even have any video encoder chips on the motherboard (Sega continued this on all French DIN8 systems, and only changed when they switched to the DIN9 connector with the Mega Drive 2)

The components included in the Sega 3085's box to buffer/amplify the RGB signals on French consoles are definitely not the correct components specified in the video encoder datasheets used in Mega Drive 1's from outside of France, which typically have the DIN8 ports connected to the video encoders RGB output. However what effect this RGB 'double buffering' will have on the video quality (When using the French 3085 SCART cable on a Japanese Mega Drive) I cant say...
Hmm the Model 3085 adaptor is working just fine with my JPN MD, I just modded it the way Segakore instructed by changing the sync signal source from CSYNC to CVBS (which turns out to be silly in terms of video quality, with the jailbars), but this 'double buffering' doesn't seem to bring ill effects.
However, thanks for the info, I will have to remove the components in the Model 3085 to bring it to specs for the JPN MD.
Here's the diagram of what the 3085 does:
Spoiler
Image
The reason for doing the Segakore mod is because what the Model 3085 does for CSYNC only works on the french RGB MD, and not on JPN MD.
But there seem to be a better way : simply removing the R19 resistor.
User avatar
Link83
Posts: 342
Joined: Tue May 21, 2013 2:39 am

Re: Conservatively modding a JPN Model1 Megadrive (VA4)

Post by Link83 »

TheShadowRunner wrote: Hmm the Model 3085 adaptor is working just fine with my JPN MD, I just modded it the way Segakore instructed by changing the sync signal source from CSYNC to CVBS (which turns out to be silly in terms of video quality, with the jailbars), but this 'double buffering' doesn't seem to bring ill effects.
However, thanks for the info, I will have to remove the components in the Model 3085 to bring it to specs for the JPN MD.
Here's the diagram of what the 3085 does:
Spoiler
Image
The reason for doing the Segakore mod is because what the Model 3085 does for CSYNC only works on the french RGB MD, and not on JPN MD.
But there seem to be a better way : simply removing the R19 resistor.
If you are considering altering the 3085 that much, then you may want to consider purchasing a higher quality ready made MD1 SCART cable from Retro Access or RGC instead. The 3085 can still be very useful for the Sega Mark III, which needs the RGB output to be amplified/buffered, or if you are already happy with the picture quality just keep it as it is. It just seems a shame to modify the 3085 into a cable which can still be readily purchased, but obviously the choice is yours.
User avatar
TheShadowRunner
Posts: 273
Joined: Sun Feb 24, 2013 7:41 pm

Re: Conservatively modding a JPN Model1 Megadrive (VA4)

Post by TheShadowRunner »

Link83 wrote: If you are considering altering the 3085 that much, then you may want to purchase a higher quality ready made MD1 SCART cable from Retro Access or RGC.

The 3085 can still be very useful for the Sega Mark III, which needs the RGB output to be amplified/buffered. It just seems a shame to change it into a cable which can still be readily purchased.
Well you're right but I have this one on hand already and getting a higher quality cable would still require me to mod it (as I will mod the DIN8 for Stereo), not to mention the cost.
While I don't mind altering the 3085, I will do it conservatively too ^^
Were you able to make sense of the 3085 diagram? Isn't it strange that it's meant for both the Euro MD and Euro Mark III if they don't output the same signals at their DIN8?
User avatar
Link83
Posts: 342
Joined: Tue May 21, 2013 2:39 am

Re: Conservatively modding a JPN Model1 Megadrive (VA4)

Post by Link83 »

TheShadowRunner wrote: Well you're right but I have this one on hand already and getting a higher quality cable would still require me to mod it (as I will mod the DIN8 for Stereo), not to mention the cost.
While I don't mind altering the 3085, I will do it conservatively too ^^
Were you able to make sense of the 3085 diagram? Isn't it strange that it's meant for both the Euro MD and Euro Mark III if they don't output the same signals at their DIN8?
I believe Retro Access offer custom cables on request, so you could request one with a modified pinout? Also you mentioned wanting to keep the front headphone jack in working order, so I wondered if you had considered using a 3.5mm headphone jack splitter?

The Model 3085 is only intended to be used with French Master System 1/2 and Mega Drive 1 systems, not European PAL Sega systems which are different. The French systems were country specific and only designed to be used and sold in France due to SECAM. There is no Euro Sega Mark III as it was only released in Asian regions, it just happens to also be compatible with the 3085 due to having a similar internal setup.

I assume Sega's thought process was that since none of the video encoder chips used in the Master System supported SECAM there was no point in including them inside French systems. Its hard to say why exactly they decided to buffer/amplify the RGB signals externally though, instead of internally on the system motherboard.

In my opinion it would have made much more sense for Sega to continue using video encoder chips on the French systems (Even though they didnt support SECAM) If only to buffer the RGB signals. However Sega's designers obviously felt otherwise, and once the design decision was taken with the first French Master System they had to continue it with the French Master System 2 and Mega Drive 1 to maintain compatibility with the Model 3085 cable, since all three systems use the same DIN8 port.

Please note that i'm not an expert in these matters, I dont live in France and all this info is just what I have picked up from forums posts over the years. If anyone else has further information to add I would love to hear it :)
User avatar
TheShadowRunner
Posts: 273
Joined: Sun Feb 24, 2013 7:41 pm

Re: Conservatively modding a JPN Model1 Megadrive (VA4)

Post by TheShadowRunner »

Link83 wrote:I believe Retro Access offer custom cables on request, so you could request one with a modified pinout? Also you mentioned wanting to keep the front headphone jack in working order, so I wondered if you had considered using a 3.5mm headphone jack splitter?
For the cable I'll stick with the 3085, saving 40 bucks and time in the process ^^;
I don't think I'll be modifying it too much.
For video: just restore CSYNC as sync source, remove resistor 19 that's doing troubles and fit the 75ohm resistor + 220uF cap in series in there (or is it better to fit them inside the console before the Din8? It shouldn't make any difference, right?)
For audio: switch either the +5v pin or CVBS pin to Right audio channel.
Regarding the headphone jack, the sound it outputs is pretty bad (noisy), and having a cable constantly connected isn't esthetically pleasing either ^^;
I just wish to keep it working for integrity's sake.
Link83 wrote:The Model 3085 is only intended to be used with French Master System 1/2 and Mega Drive 1 systems, not European PAL Sega systems which are different. The French systems were country specific and only designed to be used and sold in France due to SECAM. There is no Euro Sega Mark III as it was only released in Asian regions, it just happens to also be compatible with the 3085 due to having a similar internal setup.
Oh, got you for the Mark III. I really don't get how Secam makes any difference whatsoever when it comes to RGB, I mean Sync is Sync, there's no such thing as Secam sync..?
I grasp it has a direct impact on CVBS, but this signal isn't even wired on French RGB MD, so what the heck?
Link83 wrote:In my opinion it would have made much more sense for Sega to continue using video encoder chips on the French systems (Even though they didnt support SECAM) If only to buffer the RGB signals. However Sega's designers obviously felt otherwise, and once the design decision was taken with the first Master System they had to continue it with the Master System 2 and Mega Drive 1 to mainitain compatbility with the Model 3085 cable, since all three systems use the DIN8 port.
Hmm wait, doesn't the french MD1 contain an internal video encoder? (CXA1145 like in the other regions?)
User avatar
Link83
Posts: 342
Joined: Tue May 21, 2013 2:39 am

Re: Conservatively modding a JPN Model1 Megadrive (VA4)

Post by Link83 »

TheShadowRunner wrote:Oh, got you for the Mark III. I really don't get how Secam makes any difference whatsoever when it comes to RGB, I mean Sync is Sync, there's no such thing as Secam sync..?
I grasp it has a direct impact on CVBS, but this signal isn't even wired on French RGB MD, so what the heck?
...and thats exactly why Sega's designers likely decided not to include a video encoder in French systems, because RGB is RGB, and since most SECAM TV's didn't support PAL signals why bother to include a video encoder chip for an incompatible standard (PAL) thats not supported by French TV's? Might as well just connect the VDP RGB signals directly to the DIN8 port...
TheShadowRunner wrote: Hmm wait, doesn't the french MD1 contain an internal video encoder? (CXA1145 like in the other regions?)
As far as I have been able to tell from googling the French MD1 (Model 1600-09) doesn't have composite video output, so it would seem likely there isn't any video encoder.
User avatar
TheShadowRunner
Posts: 273
Joined: Sun Feb 24, 2013 7:41 pm

Re: Conservatively modding a JPN Model1 Megadrive (VA4)

Post by TheShadowRunner »

Link83 wrote:As far as I have been able to tell from googling the French MD1 (Model 1600-09) doesn't have composite video output, so it would seem likely there isn't any video encoder.
Hmm while CVBS isn't connected (or even generated?) it seems they do have the video encoder:
https://youtu.be/x64pXFihiK4 @5min40s
User avatar
TheShadowRunner
Posts: 273
Joined: Sun Feb 24, 2013 7:41 pm

Re: Conservatively modding a JPN Model1 Megadrive (VA4)

Post by TheShadowRunner »

Ok so while the audio mod components are on their way, I checked the video (CSYNC) mod again.
And there's a mismatch as to how it should be modified before reaching the display.

For most, to bring the Megadrive CSYNC signal to an appropriate level, 2 things are needed:
- a 220 uF cap (up to a 470uF cap)
- a 75 ohm resistor

This has been confirmed to me by many users here + official CXA 1145 datasheet, japanese modders and more.

--

Yet retrorgb is adamant that MD CSYNC requires:
- a 220 uF capacitor
- a 470 ohm resistor

And others seem to agree.

So which is it for the resistor, 75 ohm or 470 ohm...?

(I'm not sure if it makes any difference but this is for a JPN VA4)
User avatar
Fudoh
Posts: 13015
Joined: Mon Mar 06, 2006 3:29 am
Location: Germany
Contact:

Re: Conservatively modding a JPN Model1 Megadrive (VA4)

Post by Fudoh »

220uF + 75 ohm is to bring CSYNC up the specs (TTL) and make it work at all.

The higher resistor includes the attenuation needed to use CSYNC as a composite video replacement in Scart RGB environments.
MKL
Posts: 407
Joined: Wed Feb 02, 2005 9:33 pm
Location: Pordenone, Italy

Re: Conservatively modding a JPN Model1 Megadrive (VA4)

Post by MKL »

TheShadowRunner wrote: For most, to bring the Megadrive CSYNC signal to an appropriate level, 2 things are needed:
- a 220 uF cap (up to a 470uF cap)
- a 75 ohm resistor

This has been confirmed to me by many users here + official CXA 1145 datasheet,
The CXA1145 on the Mega Drive doesn't output CSYNC. If it did, then you would need 75 ohm + 220uF but it doesn't...
User avatar
TheShadowRunner
Posts: 273
Joined: Sun Feb 24, 2013 7:41 pm

Re: Conservatively modding a JPN Model1 Megadrive (VA4)

Post by TheShadowRunner »

Fudoh wrote:220uF + 75 ohm is to bring CSYNC up the specs (TTL) and make it work at all.

The higher resistor includes the attenuation needed to use CSYNC as a composite video replacement in Scart RGB environments.
Alright, that explains it, So with the targets being a BVM and a XRGB Mini, I could get away with only a 75 ohm resistor for the BVM (since it takes TTL directly) but that wouldn't be enough for the Mini, if I get it right?
MKL wrote:The CXA1145 on the Mega Drive doesn't output CSYNC. If it did, then you would need 75 ohm + 220uF but it doesn't...
Hmm but it sure does..
User avatar
Fudoh
Posts: 13015
Joined: Mon Mar 06, 2006 3:29 am
Location: Germany
Contact:

Re: Conservatively modding a JPN Model1 Megadrive (VA4)

Post by Fudoh »

Alright, that explains it, So with the targets being a BVM and a XRGB Mini, I could get away with only a 75 ohm resistor for the BVM (since it takes TTL directly) but that wouldn't be enough for the Mini, if I get it right?
as long as you don't have any monitor or switch that requires TTL, don't use it. Go with the higher resistor, since it will work fine on both the BVM and the FM.
User avatar
TheShadowRunner
Posts: 273
Joined: Sun Feb 24, 2013 7:41 pm

Re: Conservatively modding a JPN Model1 Megadrive (VA4)

Post by TheShadowRunner »

Fudoh wrote:as long as you don't have any monitor or switch that requires TTL, don't use it. Go with the higher resistor, since it will work fine on both the BVM and the FM.
Great, thank you!
As for the R/G/B lines, should I use 220uF + 75 ohm as instructed almost everywhere, or only 47 ohm resistors?
So many sources with different data..
User avatar
Fudoh
Posts: 13015
Joined: Mon Mar 06, 2006 3:29 am
Location: Germany
Contact:

Re: Conservatively modding a JPN Model1 Megadrive (VA4)

Post by Fudoh »

the difference in brightness would be minimal. I've always been using 75 ohms as far as I can remember.
User avatar
TheShadowRunner
Posts: 273
Joined: Sun Feb 24, 2013 7:41 pm

Re: Conservatively modding a JPN Model1 Megadrive (VA4)

Post by TheShadowRunner »

Fudoh wrote:the difference in brightness would be minimal. I've always been using 75 ohms as far as I can remember.
Thank you again, time to order more parts 8)
User avatar
TheShadowRunner
Posts: 273
Joined: Sun Feb 24, 2013 7:41 pm

Re: Conservatively modding a JPN Model1 Megadrive (VA4)

Post by TheShadowRunner »

An update:
The component I'm missing (470 ohm resistor) for the video mod is on the way.
I also received everything for the audio mod and dove in..
Again this is what I aim to replicate:
Image

I decided to do the mod on the bottom of the board, piggybacking the new LM358N "under" the original one.
Spoiler
Image
What I did was:
- remove resistor R43 to prevent audio mixing
- solder a wire with a 10k ohm resistor (to replicate R43) going to the op amp (which is exactly similar to the stock one, LM358N by Signetics).
- soldered a 33k resistor between pin 1 and 2 of the op amp
- soldered a 10 uF cap on the exit pin (pin1) of the op amp (positive side towards the audio-out)
- tested continuity / shorts, all good
- finally tested!
It does work, but the sound is too loud, clipping and a bit crackling versus the other channel :(

To troubleshoot the issue, I went to hunt for the volume levels at different places in the audio "stage".
Also I used this for reference:
Spoiler
Image
I hooked my headphone jack to ground and the other wire to different points, here are the results:
---
- Pin 1 (L channel) of CXA1034: volume very low
- Pin 8 (R channel) of CXA1034: volume very low
(both expected results, ok)
---
- Pin 2 of original LM358 (was mono, now L channel): volume marginally higher, still very low
- Pin 2 of mod LM358 (R channel), same as above.
(expected too, mod 10k resistor acts the same way as R42 does for the other channel, so far so good).
---
- to mod 10uF cap (positive side as per schematic, red wire on the image above): bad clipping sound, volume too high, the problem.
- to Pin 8 (audio-in) of the CXA1145 (= C30 positive side), same behavior, volume too high, clipping!
So the original left channel at this point is the same as my modded Right. Unexpected but it shows that up to this point the recreation of R channel is faithful
.
---
Then the official way goes from Pin9 (audio out) of the CXA1145 to positive side of C31 (also a 10uF cap) and finally C31 negative side is connected to Din8.
And here it becomes the twilight zone...
- to Pin 9 (audio out) of CXA1145, blue wire on the image above (= C31 positive side): I get no audio / signal, test point is silent, wtf..!?
- to C31 negative side (= Din8 audio pin): I get perfect line-out L channel volume, great sound quality!

So the CXA1145 is clearly doing some magic here, the fact I'm getting no audio signal out of its pin9 (audio out) is extremely strange too!
From the specsheet it says it's "buffer" and then there's another cap C31, that's generating good sound back somehow.

How are modders who used this method (Konsolkongen, Fudoh) not getting (way) above line-out volume and clipping sound out of the piggybacked LM358 when even the original design [before going to CXA1145] exhibits this behavior?
I'm at a loss here.. o_O
Post Reply