Muchi Muchi Spork wrote:
Which is why PSSC was the most satisfying hack release of all time. Virtually everyone thought it was official or might be then made a judgement based on that, then way later found out it was a hack and had to confront their feelings of likely illogically liking it less because the people programming it weren't getting a Cave paycheck. Absolutely delicious.
What the hell? Don't you think you are reading a bit much into this.
I have no interest in Pink Sweets either way, but I would have an interest in Cave actually having some bit of focus on shooters at this point in time, even if it all it amounted to were after-hour hobby tweaks to their old games.
I never thought Suicide Club was an official Cave release, and I doubt most other people thought that either, but I liked entertaining the thought.
Official Cave or not, having an alternate version of the game that supposedly fixes most of its issues is appreciated no matter who made it. Over time it might even gain some traction, who knows? People really appreciate the EspGaluda arrange mode from the PS2 release, and as far as I know, Cave had nothing to do with that either.
The biggest issue with any alternate (and improved) version of a game that was never a part of any official release - ie. a romhack - is that this version very rarely becomes the accepted way to compete in said game.
Even if you aren't good at the game, or don't care much about the international competition of any version of Pink Sweets, there's a certain satisfaction to playing "the real" version of a game. People don't play Donkey Kong with the original, much more sensible, stage progression of the Japanese version, because "the official" competition is in the final of the American revisions. People want to play "the real one", and it's always gonna be tough for a fan product to be accepted as "the real one", that goes without saying. They usually end their life cycle at "curious novelty".
If you think there's a bunch of "absolutely delicious" disappointed Cave fanboys hanging out around this most despicable forum, feeling like idiots for liking something that turned out not to be Cave, I think you're probably gonna be disappointed.